nanog mailing list archives
RE: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3)
From: Leigh Porter <leigh.porter () ukbroadband com>
Date: Wed, 29 Jun 2011 14:45:12 +0000
Well, then you run into the nice problem of the RNCs only having 400kilobytes of buffers per session and will drop packets if they receive more packets than that, or sometimes even just because they receive a burst of a few tens of packets at GigE linerate (because the customer with large TCP window size is talking to a GigE connected server).The recommended "solution" from the vendor was to tune the client toa smaller TCP window size so that their RNC wouldn't get such a large burst.*sigh*Sounds like a vendor specific issue :( Good tcp vs default tcp will not close the window tight due to some ephemeral loss or delay. The penalties are generally too strong in tcp for the issues of delay and loss in 3g ... this is one of the main selling points for tcp proxies .... but better done with modern tcp on the clients instead of a middle box
Indeed it does sound like a vendor issue. The network I was running did just fine with the FastSoft proxy boxes. In fact, they were so effective that we almost doubled our TCP throughput overnight! We did not quite get a chance to explore the interaction between the TCP proxies and the algorithms that supposedly fixed TCP in the vendors GGSN (TCP window size fiddling) and the interaction of the new TCP protocol with the 3G base station scheduler, but the results kind of spoke for themselves really. Similarly we have had good results with WiMAX networks. -- Leigh Porter UK Broadband ______________________________________________________________________ This email has been scanned by the MessageLabs Email Security System. For more information please visit http://www.messagelabs.com/email ______________________________________________________________________
Current thread:
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3), (continued)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Cameron Byrne (Jun 28)
- RE: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Leigh Porter (Jun 28)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Cameron Byrne (Jun 28)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) PC (Jun 28)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Cameron Byrne (Jun 28)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Mikael Abrahamsson (Jun 28)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Tony Finch (Jun 29)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Nick Hilliard (Jun 29)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Mikael Abrahamsson (Jun 29)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Cameron Byrne (Jun 29)
- RE: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Leigh Porter (Jun 29)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Mikael Abrahamsson (Jun 29)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Cameron Byrne (Jun 29)
- Re: Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Ryan Malayter (Jun 29)
- Re: Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Steven Bellovin (Jun 29)
- Re: Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Cameron Byrne (Jun 29)
- Re: [pfSense Support] Strange TCP connection behavior 2.0 RC2 (+3) Hank Nussbacher (Jun 29)