nanog mailing list archives
Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions
From: Leo Bicknell <bicknell () ufp org>
Date: Fri, 18 Feb 2011 13:29:12 -0800
In a message written on Fri, Feb 18, 2011 at 02:34:21PM -0500, Christopher Morrow wrote:
why is it a good idea to send this to your customers? the next-hop info is surely only useful to your local network? done right it's even only relevant to the IX connected router, right? it seems wholely unusful to your customers. (to me at least)
If by "done right" you mean perhaps a feature like returning ICMP's from a loopback IP rather than the interface IP, there are two issues with that: The far end ISP controls this feature. If they don't enable it you must work around by announcing the prefix to your customer. One person doing it wrong at the exchange is enough that you have to work around it. I at least find it useful when traceroute shows the interface. I believe it saves time for your NOC, and burning IP's for interfaces makes a lot of sense in terms of speeding troubleshooting. Even if all of my gear allowed me to send ICMP's from the loopback it's quite likely I would not use that feature. -- Leo Bicknell - bicknell () ufp org - CCIE 3440 PGP keys at http://www.ufp.org/~bicknell/
Attachment:
_bin
Description:
Current thread:
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions, (continued)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Randy Bush (Feb 17)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Yaoqing(Joey) Liu (Feb 17)
- RE: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Michael K. Smith - Adhost (Feb 18)
- RE: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Michael K. Smith - Adhost (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Christopher Morrow (Feb 18)
- RE: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Michael K. Smith - Adhost (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Christopher Morrow (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Leo Bicknell (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Christopher Morrow (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Joe Abley (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Leo Bicknell (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Christopher Morrow (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Leo Bicknell (Feb 18)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Martin Pels (Feb 19)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Randy Bush (Feb 17)
- Re: Internet Exchange Point(IXP) questions Bill Woodcock (Feb 17)