nanog mailing list archives
Re: IPv4 Exhaustion...
From: nick hatch <nicholas.hatch () gmail com>
Date: Fri, 23 Jul 2010 15:16:06 -0700
On Fri, Jul 23, 2010 at 10:11 AM, Positively Optimistic < positivelyoptimistic () gmail com> wrote:
How do ISPs handle RIAA notices when NATTING customers.. ? We have several customers that don't require public address space that could be moved to private.. We're reluctant to make the move due to legal liabilities..
It might be helpful to review the requirements for DMCA Safe Harbor for conduit communication providers, specifically section 512(a). It's been my experience that some networks (.edu's in particular) have voluntarily expanded their actions in response to DMCA complaints, and will sometimes falsely attribute these actions to DMCA requirements. If I recall correctly, the primary responsibilities for a conduit provider are limited to terminating repeat offenders, and informing subscribers of this policy. The DMCA doesn't explicitly define what a repeat offender is, nor does it explicitly mandate specific logging measures. If a provider makes best-effort attempts to correlate complaints to subscribers in order to track repeat offenders, I'm not sure there is a liability problem here. -Nick
Current thread:
- IPv4 Exhaustion... Positively Optimistic (Jul 23)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... David E. Smith (Jul 23)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... William Herrin (Jul 23)
- RE: IPv4 Exhaustion... Lee Howard (Jul 23)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Ricky Beam (Jul 26)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Michael Thomas (Jul 26)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Ricky Beam (Jul 26)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... nick hatch (Jul 23)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Barry Shein (Jul 24)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... khatfield (Jul 23)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Steven Bellovin (Jul 23)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Ricky Beam (Jul 23)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Leo Vegoda (Jul 23)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Owen DeLong (Jul 24)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Christopher Morrow (Jul 24)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Valdis . Kletnieks (Jul 24)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Christopher Morrow (Jul 24)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Ricky Beam (Jul 26)
- Re: IPv4 Exhaustion... Steven Bellovin (Jul 23)