Re: MAC address confusion

["R. Kevin Oberman" <oberman () es net>]

Sorry fot the top-post, but my Treo makes it almost impossible to do otherwise.

The protocols using these reserved, local addresses all use them to embed the network layer address. AA addresses are 
used by DECnet and kin while 02 is for XNS, I seem to recall. 

 As long as the only addresses used in these spaces are thse asigned by those protocols and they use peoperly assigned 
network layer addresses, ther will never be a conflict. That is the point in0the registration...marking them as 
reserved for the protocols in question and not to be used for anything else.
Sent from my Treo:
R. Kevin Oberman, Network Engineer
Energy Sciences Network (ESnet)
E. O. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL)
oberman () es net                      +1 510-486-8634

-----Original Message-----
From: Saku Ytti <saku+nanog () ytti fi>
Date: Wednesday, Mar 4, 2009 12:49 am
Subject: Re: MAC address confusion
To: nanog () nanog org

On (2009-03-03 13:50 -0800), Kevin Oberman wrote:

> This is only a problem if you have multiple systems running DECnet (or
 some other protocol using this) with the same layer 3 address. That
 should never happen, so there should be no duplication.

Why would they need to have same L3 address? The way I see it, only thing that matters is, if or not, the addresses 
might speak ethernetII. If your ethernetII switch sees your local 02 address and one of the addresses below and they 
collide, the switch will keep relearning the address behind two ports. Unless of course it is guaranteed, that none of 
these addresses will ever appear as BIA in ethernetII capable NIC.

02-07-01   (hex)                RACAL-DATACOM
02-1C-7C   (hex)                PERQ SYSTEMS CORPORATION
02-60-86   (hex)                LOGIC REPLACEMENT TECH. LTD.
02-60-8C   (hex)                3COM CORPORATION
02-70-01   (hex)                RACAL-DATACOM
02-70-B0   (hex)                M/A-COM INC. COMPANIES
02-70-B3   (hex)                DATA RECALL LTD
02-9D-8E   (hex)                CARDIAC RECORDERS INC.
02-AA-3C   (hex)                OLIVETTI TELECOMM SPA (OLTECO)
02-BB-01   (hex)                OCTOTHORPE CORP.
02-C0-8C   (hex)                3COM CORPORATION
02-CF-1C   (hex)                COMMUNICATION MACHINERY CORP.
02-E6-D3   (hex)                NIXDORF COMPUTER CORPORATION

-- 
  ++ytti