RE: Global Blackhole Service

[Skywing <Skywing () valhallalegends com>]

Of course, whomever hosts such a service becomes an attractive DoS target themselves if it were ever to gain real 
traction in the field.  There is also the "reverse-DoS" issue of an innocent party getting into the feed if anyone can 
peer with it.

- S

-----Original Message-----
From: Nuno Vieira - nfsi telecom <nuno.vieira () nfsi pt>
Sent: Friday, February 13, 2009 07:13
To: Jens Ott - PlusServer AG <j.ott () plusserver de>
Cc: nanog <nanog () nanog org>
Subject: Re: Global Blackhole Service


Hi Jens,

I think we are in the same boat.

We suffered the same problem often, on a lower magnitude, but if a project like this exists those DDoS could even be 
almost near zero.

This is somewhat similar to what Spamcop, and other folks do with SPAM today, but applied on a diferent scope, say, BGP 
Blackhole.

This service can span wide after just peers, opening the opportunity to edge-to-edge DDoS mitigation.

Say, a network in .pt or .de is beign attacked at large, and dst operators inject the dst attacked source on the 
blackhole bgp feed...   say that 100+ other ops around the world use a cenário like this... this might be very useful.
concers: the "autohority" or the "responsible" for maintaining this project, must assure that OP A or OP B can *only* 
annouce chunks that below to him, avoiding any case of hijack.

We would be interested in participating in something like this.

So,

> My questions to all of you:
>
> - - What do you think about such service?

It will be great. We are available to help.

> - - Would you/your ASN participate in such a service?

Yes.

> - - Do you see some kind of usefull feature in such a service?

Yes, a few thoughts above, some more might come up.

> - - Do you have any comments?

For starters, a few above.

Regards,
---
Nuno Vieira
nfsi telecom, lda.

nuno.vieira () nfsi pt
Tel. (+351) 21 949 2300 - Fax (+351) 21 949 2301
http://www.nfsi.pt/



----- "Jens Ott - PlusServer AG" <j.ott () plusserver de> wrote:

> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
> Hash: SHA1
>
> Hi,
>
> in the last 24 hours we received two denial of service attacks with
> something
> like 6-8GBit volume. It did not harm us too much, but e.g. one of our
> upstreams got his Amsix-Port exploded.
>
> With our upstreams we have remote-blackhole sessions running where we
> announce
> /32 prefixes to blackhole at their edge, but this does not work with
> our
> peers. Also our Decix-Port received something like 2Gbit extra-traffic
> during
> this DoS.
>
> I can imagine, that for some peers, especially for the once having
> only a thin
> fiber (e.g. 1GBit) to Decix, it's not to funny having it flooded with
> a DoS
> and that they might be interested in dropping such traffic at their
> edge.
>
> Well I could discuss with my peers (at least the once who might get in
> trouble
> with such issue) to do some individual config for some
> blackhole-announcement,
> but most probably I'm not the only one receiving DoS and who would be
> interested in such setup.
>
> Therefore I had the following idea: Why not taking one of my old
> routers and
> set it up as blackhole-service. Then everyone who is interested could
> set up a
> session to there and
>
> 1.) announce /32 (/128) routes out of his prefixes to blackhole them
> 2.) receive all the /32 (/128) announcements from the other peers with
> the IPs
> they want to have blackholed and rollout the blackhole to their
> network.
>
> My questions to all of you:
>
> - - What do you think about such service?
> - - Would you/your ASN participate in such a service?
> - - Do you see some kind of usefull feature in such a service?
> - - Do you have any comments?
>
> Thank you for telling me your opinions and best regards
>
> - --
> ===================================================================
>
> Jens Ott
> Leiter Network Management
>
> Tel: +49 22 33 - 612 - 3501
> Fax: +49 22 33 - 612 - 53501
>
> E-Mail: j.ott () plusserver de
> GPG-Fingerprint: 808A EADF C476 FABE 2366  8402 31FD 328C C2CA 7D7A
>
> PlusServer AG
> Daimlerstraße 9-11
> 50354 Hürth
>
> Germany
>
> HRB 58428 / Amtsgericht Köln, USt-ID DE216 740 823
> Vorstand: Jochen Berger, Frank Gross, Jan Osthues, Thomas Strohe
> Aufsichtsratsvorsitz: Claudius Schmalschläger
>
> ===================================================================
>
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
> Version: GnuPG v2.0.9 (GNU/Linux)
> Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org
>
> iEYEARECAAYFAkmVilwACgkQMf0yjMLKfXpNuQCeKcicthIadISe7I+Xs5ZNHS+1
> 0qUAnRDkOY9/6kokq3Hf68BRQFfkP3xy
> =jKUA
> -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----