nanog mailing list archives
RE: Arrogant RBL list maintainers
From: "Frank Bulk" <frnkblk () iname com>
Date: Wed, 9 Dec 2009 21:08:07 -0600
Michael: I've seen their form, too. I think you're reading too much into their policies/requests. Does it matter if they label your non e-mail server IPs as dynamic space, and therefore put it on their DUL? Frank -----Original Message----- From: Michael Holstein [mailto:michael.holstein () csuohio edu] Sent: Wednesday, December 09, 2009 3:18 PM To: Ken Chase Cc: nanog () nanog org Subject: Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers
To be clear: because the legitimate mailserver with a proper non-generic reverse was in a block with other generic reverses, they blacklisted you?
Their initial email said : [snip] Trend Micro Notification: 137.148.0.0/16 added to DUL [snip] and then went on to say : [snip] To work with us, please generate the following three lists: 1) TOTAL ALLOCATED SPACE - in CIDR format Please include all information for the space you announce. The total of Static and Dynamic space must equal the Total Allocated Space. 2) DYNAMIC SPACE LIST - in CIDR format 3) STATIC SPACE LIST - in CIDR Format [snip] Which was, of course, impossible .. since trunking a VLAN across the core just to have all the printers in the same /22 would be silly. After some arguing back-and-forth .. they (Trend) said : [snip] Also we don't see the IP address as static as we see the generic naming convention of *csuohio.edu* as dynamic and the WHOIS information doesn't indicate that the space is static. [snip] Seriously .. we're a college campus, not a colo. Org-Abuse roles is defined (and valid) and real people read the RFC2142 required addresses. What more do these people want? (Note: they did eventually say "okay, we see the MXs as static so those aren't listed" .. but not without some discussion). Cheers, Michael Holstein Cleveland State University
Current thread:
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers, (continued)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Michael Holstein (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Seth Mattinen (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Ken Chase (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Valdis . Kletnieks (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Michael Holstein (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Jon Lewis (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers John Levine (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Michael Holstein (Dec 10)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Steven Champeon (Dec 10)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Michael Holstein (Dec 10)
- RE: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Frank Bulk (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Chris Edwards (Dec 10)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Tony Finch (Dec 10)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Ronald Cotoni (Dec 10)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Michelle Sullivan (Dec 16)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Niels Bakker (Dec 16)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Michelle Sullivan (Dec 16)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers John Levine (Dec 09)
- Re: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Michael Holstein (Dec 09)
- RE: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Frank Bulk (Dec 09)
- RE: Arrogant RBL list maintainers Mikael Abrahamsson (Dec 09)