nanog mailing list archives

Re: Presumed RF Interference


From: "Jon R. Kibler" <Jon.Kibler () aset com>
Date: Sun, 05 Mar 2006 17:37:13 -0500

David Lesher wrote:

Given what I have described, would you think this is an RF interference problem?

No...


Unless you have a Gigawatt radar parked next door, I'm highly dubious
that it's RF-instigated.



A) All these things say grounding issues. I have to wonder if
the building is fed from more than one power entrance. The blown
patch panel especially makes me think the router on one end of
the Cat5 was being fed from a different power source than the
one on the other. (Which pair was blown?) Given the UPS mention,
maybe there's a ground differential issue with it.

B) The other, less likely, path into equipment is telco. Those
mile-long pieces of copper from the CO are also called "antennas"
and they covet static. I have no idea where this location is --
are there thunderstorms around?

C) One more possibility; perhaps some piece of equipment in-house
is putting large spikes on the internal distribution. Twenty years
ago, I read of a building where large [50 HP HVAC] and small
[fridges] motors would regularly die. The high-tech gadgets of
that era, Texas Instruments calculators, would reset themselves
seemingly spontaneously. After MUCH work, they found the BIG
copier was putting nasty spikes back on the grid.

I vote A) 75% B) 20% C) 5%

Re: C, I think (hope) the power company has already eliminated internal power spikes. The have recording monitors on 
both the building feed and on the distribution panels for the office area. The only thing in the building that pulls 
more than 20A is a couple of 4 ton A/C units and the server room UPS. 

Re: B, The "telco lines are antennas" concept is why we were thinking RF. The location is in the SE US, but no 
thunderstorms this time of the year.

Re: A, I don't remember which pair was blown. Since it was a new patch panel (less than a week old) we initially wrote 
it off as a manufacturing defect -- but now we are not so sure. Everything in the server room -- which includes PBX and 
all networking equipment -- is on a single UPS. The CAT6 in the building terminates at PCs. Each PC has its own 
separate UPS. A floating ground or ground current was among my first thoughts -- but a few things about it bugged me 
and made me look elsewhere:
   1) How could a bad ground cause DSL line noise that ia inaudible? Also, the noise is on the telco side, not the LAN 
side.
   2) Why would it be blowing DSL routers that are isolated from the LAN by a switch and another router? And, all of 
this equipment is in the same rack, on the same ground, and on the same UPS.

Well David, thanks for your thoughts. I guess the next step is to find an EE that want to tackle this challenge without 
asking for an open-ended purse!

Jon Kibler
-- 
Jon R. Kibler
Chief Technical Officer
A.S.E.T., Inc.
Charleston, SC  USA
(843) 849-8214




==================================================
Filtered by: TRUSTEM.COM's Email Filtering Service
http://www.trustem.com/
No Spam. No Viruses. Just Good Clean Email.


Current thread: