nanog mailing list archives

national hardware price quote registry - project clarifications


From: "Matt Bazan" <Mbazan () onelegal com>
Date: Sat, 17 Sep 2005 13:03:04 -0700


There's been a fair bit of confusion as to what the price quote registry is about.  As this confusion is mainly due to 
my lack of clarity I hope this email will rectify the ambiguity.  Let me set the record straight on what my original 
intentions for this project were:  

1)  The original intent of the project was an online price quote registry aimed at small to medium businesses for 
quotes in the $20-$100K range.  Larger quotes would of course be welcome but as these are almost always bound by NDAs 
in all likelihood these quotes would rarely find their way into the registry.
2)  I do not, have not, and will not advocate people violate their respective NDAs (or quote confidentiality clauses).  
However, if a person chooses to do so that's their perogative hence the anonymous nature of the system.
3)  I never intended the registry to be for 'big ticket' items.  I, personally, have no interest in those.  The thread 
seemed to devolve into discussing multi-million dollar quotes and the ramifications of opening up this process to 
public inspection.  While I disagree with many of the conclusions that my fellow NANOGers have drawn about the likely 
outcome of opening this process up, I understand your concerns.  My interest lies in the much smaller sub $100K quotes 
that are not bound by NDAs.
4)  If, as others have suggested, you don't like the sytem, then don't use it.  If enough people feel this will it will 
soon whither into the ether.

  Matt







Current thread: