nanog mailing list archives

Re: Underscores in host names


From: bmanning () vacation karoshi com
Date: Wed, 18 May 2005 18:33:46 +0000


However, that rant was mostly irrelevant.  Can you point to _ANY_
application, operating system, or anything else that has any issues
whatsoever with an "_" of all characters?

at the time of check-names, i outlawed _ as a side effect of punting.  in
order to strip/prevent newline characters in PTR targets, i had to be able
to refer to an RFC (lest people come to me with many individual sob stories
about this or that special character that either should or should not be
stripped/prevented in gethostbyaddr().)  the only RFC i found that had any
remote chance of getting me off this hook was #952.  ergo, _ had to die in
order that my inbox might live.

but it was wrong, and the need for it is past, and it's time for redress.

        does this mean that i can get my .com  delegation back?
        its to support ADA-act compliant web servers.

--bill


Current thread: