nanog mailing list archives
Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong!
From: "Alexei Roudnev" <alex () relcom net>
Date: Sun, 16 Jan 2005 22:30:24 -0800
Joe Maimon <jmaimon () ttec com> writes:Or perhaps do you mean previous owners can call in a "stop order" or "dispute" the transfer unilaterally within X days of occurence, much like it works for many REAL money transactions?That makes considerable sense. You should be able to call in, say "roll it back", and have it stay rolled back for a few days until someone can investigate.
It is exactly what I was talking about.
If people like Melbourne IT are going to claim they can't act on weekends, it might also be sensible not to allow transfers to be processed between Thursday and Sunday, though honestly I think if you are going to be a registrar, you are going to have to deal with problems over weekends.
It is their dirty problem - if they can not act on weekend, they can not maintain a registry, that's all.
One more disturbing problem here -- it seems (based on external evidence) that someone managed to fake out the system. Although Verisign and Melbourne IT seem to think that the transfer was approved, neither Dotster nor Panix have any record at all of it. Dotster's records make them think they are still the registrar for panix.com. It appears someone cracked the system, though whether by exploiting protocol problems or in some other way isn't clear at all.
If I am allowed to say my personal opinion here - it more likely was a technical bnug or human mistake, not a hack. But let's see. This case shiould be carefully investigated, no matte if this transfer was legal or not.
Perry
Current thread:
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Eric Brunner-Williams in Portland Maine (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Joe Maimon (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Perry E. Metzger (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Chris Adams (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Adrian Chadd (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Steve Sobol (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Jim Shankland (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Steven J. Sobol (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Paul G (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Steve Sobol (Jan 19)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Perry E. Metzger (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Joe Maimon (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Alexei Roudnev (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Christopher L. Morrow (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Richard Cox (Jan 17)
- Standard of Promptness William Allen Simpson (Jan 17)
- Re: Standard of Promptness Eric Brunner-Williams in Portland Maine (Jan 18)
- Re: Standard of Promptness John Curran (Jan 18)
- RE: Standard of Promptness David Schwartz (Jan 18)
- RE: Standard of Promptness Tim Wilde (Jan 18)