nanog mailing list archives

RE: US Extradition rights (was Re: Spamhaus Exposed)


From: cproctor () epik net
Date: Thu, 18 Mar 2004 10:47:26 -0500


Joshua Brady wrote:
The "Child" you speak of caused destruction over a network, 
the same 
applied for the 2 hackers here who were sent over without even 
questioning the UK. If the US Government is Satan then I 
suppose I am 
going to hell, because I sure as hell support it.

Do you support the converse, where some little s*** hacks my 
London network from some random US college ? At the moment, I 
have no recourse of any kind and the UK authorities have no 
power, and as a consequence, no interest.

Peter

I would have to say yes.  Globalization of trade and markets is dependant to
some degree on a commonality of law.  As you say, there's presently no
reason a US firm couldn't destroy the network of a UK firm with whom it
competes to get a competitive advantage.  If spammers are any example, then
there are people out there low enough to take advantage of such a loophole.

It is probably reasonable to expect that every country will maintain its own
speed limits and decency statues.  I do believe that crimes against people
and property should be prosecutable across international borders.
Unfortunately, that is probably a utopian dream.

Chris Proctor 


Current thread: