Re: "Default" Internet Service (was: Re: Points on your Internet driver's license)

[Randy Bush <randy () psg com>]

> > > One could imagine changing the paradigm (never easy) so that
> > > the normal Internet service was proxied for common applications
> > > and NAT'ed for everything else...  This wouldn't eliminate all the
> > > problems, but would dramatically cut down the incident rate.
> > >
> > > If a site wants wide-open access, just give it to them.  If that turns
> > > out to cause operational problems (due to open mail proxies, spam
> > > origination, etc), then put 'em back behind the relays.
> >
> > guilty until proven innocent, eh?  thanks mr ashcroft.
>
> Randy, are you objecting to the model for initial connectivity,
> or the throwing them back behind relays w/o a formal trial?

the former, see previous post about the e2e internet

if you can actually diagnose bad traffic, then you may
have a right to act

randy