nanog mailing list archives
RE: Statements against new.net?
From: Roeland Meyer <rmeyer () mhsc com>
Date: Fri, 16 Mar 2001 08:45:48 -0800
From: Miles Fidelman [mailto:mfidelman () civicnet org] Sent: Friday, March 16, 2001 5:38 AM On Thu, 15 Mar 2001, Patrick Greenwell wrote:On Thu, 15 Mar 2001, Miles Fidelman wrote:At some point cooperation has to yield to due process -at least that'sthe history of society to date. Unless there's a majorchange to theInternet infrastructure, we need DNS to functionreliably, and thatrequires that the root nameservers behave the way they'resupposed to.I don't see any problem with anything you have said. I think the difficulty comes when I tell you that the root servers Ichoose to use areoperating fine, and you attempt to tell me that I have touse yours. For the Internet to work, at least with currently accepted DNS standards, everyone has to use the same root servers. Otherwise things can rapidly degenerate into chaos. The whole point of law and due process is that a duly authorized somebody has to have the authority to insist that everyone use the same root servers.
Two problems; Who does the authorization? ... and US Constitution. There is also the not-so-small problem of global enforcement, of such a draconian measure. I'm not unsympathetic to folks paying for heldesks. But, you're gonna get those calls anyway. You may even be getting them now. Is this any different than lusers asking why their machine doesn't work ... during a blackout? You've been living in the regulated side of the telco business far too long.
Current thread:
- IP<->IP translation (was re: Statements against new.net?), (continued)
- IP<->IP translation (was re: Statements against new.net?) Clayton Fiske (Mar 15)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Roeland Meyer (Mar 15)
- RE: Statements against new.net? mdevney (Mar 15)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Kavi, Prabhu (Mar 15)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Richard A. Steenbergen (Mar 15)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Patrick Greenwell (Mar 15)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Roeland Meyer (Mar 15)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Adam Rothschild (Mar 16)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Roeland Meyer (Mar 16)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Adam Rothschild (Mar 16)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Roeland Meyer (Mar 16)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Miles Fidelman (Mar 16)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Peter Galbavy (Mar 16)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Neil J. McRae (Mar 20)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Randy Bush (Mar 16)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Miles Fidelman (Mar 16)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Jeff Workman (Mar 16)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Kevin Loch (Mar 16)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Simon Higgs (Mar 16)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Jeff Workman (Mar 17)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Henry R. Linneweh (Mar 17)
- Top Level Domain Finder Tools Simon Higgs (Mar 17)