nanog mailing list archives
Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation
From: Jeff Mcadams <jeffm () iglou com>
Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2000 08:28:31 -0400
Also sprach William Allen Simpson
"To exempt from reciprocal compensation requirements telecommunications traffic to the Internet. "
Anybody know about this? Seems like it kills payments by ILECS to CLECs for dialups, when the calls are to an ISP. Note, only _TO_ an ISP; folks wanting to provide voice are still required to pay ILECs for traffic _from_ an ISP.
Is this the "ILECs put ISPs out of business" act?
Bingo. Hit the nail on the head with that one. BellSouth has been particularly onerous about recip. comp. They've lost their PUC filings in just about every state that they've been brought up where they claim that calls are not terminated at the access server equipment, but are instead better considered as terminating somewhere out on the Internet. That they haven't even made any semblance of effort to try to determine where the calls really *do* terminate, they just do lots of hand waving about it being out on the Internet somewhere, which I find humorous, at best. This is logic that I'm convinced that only a threatened monopoly could understand. I also find it rather interesting that the ILECs were the ones that initially insisted on recip. comp., and now they're the ones whining about it being unfair. -- Jeff McAdams Email: jeffm () iglou com Head Network Administrator Voice: (502) 966-3848 IgLou Internet Services (800) 436-4456
Current thread:
- HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation William Allen Simpson (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation Jeff Mcadams (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation David Lesher (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation M. David Leonard (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation Brett Frankenberger (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation M. David Leonard (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation Bill Woodcock (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation Nathan Stratton (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation Brett Frankenberger (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation Masataka Ohta (Sep 15)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation Chip Sharp (Sep 14)
- Re: HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation David Lesher (Sep 14)
- HR 4445 Reciprocal Compensation Robert Cannon (Sep 18)