nanog mailing list archives

Re: UBR at MAE-East ATM, anyone?


From: Steve Feldman <feldman () twincreeks net>
Date: Mon, 17 Apr 2000 22:15:01 -0700


When I left wcom, there was a project starting to
implement an option to provision UBR PVCs.
It required non-trivial changes to Peermaker,
so would take some time.

I'll let the current MAE crew answer as to current state,
availability, etc.
        Steve

On Mon, Apr 17, 2000 at 10:37:17PM -0400, Alex Rubenstein wrote:


I've been talking to the WCom MAE folk, and the explained to me that the
the VC's between beers are built as ABR, with PCR being twice SCR. Also,
the port you lease from them has a non-oversubscription policy, i.e., the
sum of all SCR's combined cannot be more than port speed.

From what I can tell, PBNap and Ameritech both build the VC's as UBR, with
no over-allocation protection.

In my travels of contacting other providers for peer information, I have
run across about 5 (albeit out of about 60 who responded) that said they
couldn't turn up new VC's across MAE-East ATM, because they have reached
thier subscription allocation, even though thier port is not nearly full.
A few had even expressed they wish that it was the ameritech-like UBR
model.

One person who I spoke to at WCom had said that maybe someday they would
allow UBR PVCs, but there was no timeline.

What are other people's thoughts on this?







Current thread: