nanog mailing list archives
Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but...
From: Marc Slemko <marcs () znep com>
Date: Sun, 18 Oct 1998 11:30:37 -0700 (PDT)
On Sun, 18 Oct 1998, Patrick Greenwell wrote:
On 17 Oct 1998, Michael Shields wrote:In article <4.0.1.19981016224901.00de6240 () pariah cncx com>, I Am Not An Isp <patrick () ianai net> wrote:FACT: RFC1918 space does not break PMTU discovery. Deal with it.If you use RFC 1918 space on the Internet, PMTU very well may not work for you. You can place fault on whatever standard you like but that doesn't change the *operational* issue.1) There is nothing inherient in the use of RFC 1918 space that will break PMTU.
The only point I am trying to make is that while there is absolutely nothing in using address space as defined in RFC-1918 that will break PMTU-D, using 1918 addresses for public router interfaces which send packets to public networks (in this case, the Internet) from that address is outside the scope of what 1918 permits and can break things when combined with other entirely legitimate and correct practices. As a result, it is unwise to encourage people to use 1918 addresses in such an inappropriate way. Since everyone agrees on this, hopefully this thread can now rest.
Current thread:
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but..., (continued)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Michael Shields (Oct 16)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... I Am Not An Isp (Oct 17)
- Message not available
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... I Am Not An Isp (Oct 16)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Michael Shields (Oct 16)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Marc Slemko (Oct 16)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... I Am Not An Isp (Oct 16)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Marc Slemko (Oct 17)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Michael Shields (Oct 17)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... I Am Not An Isp (Oct 17)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Patrick Greenwell (Oct 18)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Marc Slemko (Oct 18)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Marc Slemko (Oct 14)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Tim Wolfe (Oct 14)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... I Am Not An Isp (Oct 16)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Jim Shankland (Oct 16)
- Re: Maybe I'm misreading this but... Phillip Vandry (Oct 16)