nanog mailing list archives
Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI)
From: Dorian Kim <dorian () cic net>
Date: Fri, 29 Mar 1996 20:19:45 -0500 (EST)
On Sat, 30 Mar 1996, Per Gregers Bilse wrote:
On Mar 29, 9:20, Mike Trest <trest () atmnet net> wrote:The discussions regarding ATM/SONET and IP over ATM are finally focused on a fundamental issue:The fundamental question which remains without an answer is this: In which way do my packets benefit if transported by ATM? Is it cheaper? Doesn't look like it. Do they travel faster? No. Can I send more? No. Is it simpler? No, which means more failure modes (historical evidence, if nothing else, is plentiful). Is it more reliable than the alternatives? Probably not. So what do I stand to gain?
To put it another way: What problem does ATM solve that it's alternative doesn't, and what problem does ATM create that it's alternative doesn't? You can do your own cost-benefit analysis to determine if you are interested in ATM. -dorian
Current thread:
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI), (continued)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Shikhar Bajaj (Mar 26)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Paul Ferguson (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Paul A Vixie (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Shikhar Bajaj (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Sean Doran (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Shikhar Bajaj (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Paul Ferguson (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Shikhar Bajaj (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Mike Trest (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Per Gregers Bilse (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Dorian Kim (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Curtis Villamizar (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Paul Ferguson (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Paul Ferguson (Mar 28)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) @NANOG-LIST (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Fletcher Kittredge (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) @NANOG-LIST (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) @NANOG-LIST (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Steve Steinberg (Mar 29)
- Re: SONET Interconnect (was RE: MCI) Larry J. Plato (Mar 29)