"Security is Development" - Robert McNamara, 1966

[David Farber <dave () farber net>]

Begin forwarded message:

From: Jock Gill <jg45 () mac com>
Date: August 6, 2004 10:43:46 PM EDT
To: Farber Dave <dave () farber net>
Subject: "Security is Development" - Robert McNamara, 1966

Dave,

Readers of IP might find this bit of history very worth while 
reviewing.  The work from 1966 is very well worth pondering in light of 
current events.  There is much more to McNamara than "The Fog of War" 
might lead one to believe.  Thanks to  Dave Hughes for telling me about 
it and sharing his vast store of knowledge on this topic.

Jock


Jock Gill
Media Intelligence
jock () jockgill com
(781) 577-2888

Note: This speech was delivered by Robert McNamara in 1966 when he was
disillusioned with the US efforts in South Vietnam, and the profound
misunderstanding of the nature of international conflict in the world. 
He
knew there were similar types of conflicts arising all over the world
which simply promised more chaos, and could not be dealt with cost
effectively after they got fully underway - that the communists were 
only
exploiting them for their own purposes - and that, if we wanted a
'peaceful world' much greater effort must be expended other than 
military
to prevent them.  I was his 'Assistant for Counterinsurgency' at the 
time,
and did the studies that underlay the speech and theory, and suggested 
the
central thesis that 'Security is Development' in the contemporary world,
and I crafted large sections of the speech.

It got a world wide reaction. Utter suprise at its sweep, transcending 
all
the other agencies of the US government who should have, but were not,
relating their efforts to global security and peace. (some thought he 
was
going to run for President) Later, McNamara, putting his money where his
mouth was, left the government, and took the helm as President of the
 World Bank - which attempts to support 'development' in the 3d world. 
Of
course the US public, which hates foreign aid, and understands it even
less, did nothing. And lots of the US press, which can't grasp or report
effectively on big ideas. just glomed onto the 2 year Service idea as 
the
'news' of the speech.

But if anyone cares to notice, the world since 1966 (it is now 1999) has
unfolded as McNamara predicted, and there is more political violence 
than
ever - and less ameliorative development. With the US military 
continuing
to act as the world's policeman. And the US still confused as to its 
role
in the world.

David Hughes Col, US Army, Retired.
then Lt. Col. US Army

------------------

The text of the speech is at:

< http://www.oldcolo.com/McNamara/mcnamara.txt >

(781) 577-2888

-------------------------------------
You are subscribed as interesting-people () lists elistx com
To manage your subscription, go to
 http://v2.listbox.com/member/?listname=ip

Archives at: http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/