Full Disclosure mailing list archives
Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started
From: Valdis.Kletnieks () vt edu
Date: Thu, 13 May 2004 22:09:43 -0400
On Thu, 13 May 2004 15:55:34 PDT, Mister Coffee <live4java () stormcenter net> said:
It doesn't excuse their business practices, or the original code flaws, but writing bad code isn't illegal. Lame perhaps. But not illegal.
And be careful of unintended consequences of any attempts to make bad code illegal. Remember that Microsoft is sitting on $52B in cash, and can afford to fight a charge of "criminally negligent coding". There's very few open source projects that can bankroll a legal defense if their programmers screw up. If you make programmers liable to civil actions for their screw-ups, then it's possibly almost workable - programmer insurance similar to medical malpractice insurance will spring up, rates will be set according to the perceived risk of frequency and cost of errors, and life will go on, more or less. Also - remember that there's a distinction between civil liability and criminal liability. Doctors become doctors because they can afford to pay for malpractice insurance (I'll overlook the issues in high-risk specialties). On the other hand, it's *very* hard to get a doctor convicted of criminal negligence and sent to prison for the simple reason that if the standard for getting sent to jail was anywhere near as low as for losing a malpractice suit, we'd have no medical profession left.
Attachment:
_bin
Description:
Current thread:
- Support the Sasser-author fund started support-sasser (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Tobias Weisserth (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started harry (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Tobias Weisserth (May 13)
- Re[2]: Support the Sasser-author fund started Thierry (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Valdis . Kletnieks (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Georgi Guninski (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Mister Coffee (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Valdis . Kletnieks (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Tobias Weisserth (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started harry (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Konstantin Gavrilenko (May 14)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Tobias Weisserth (May 14)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Georgi Guninski (May 15)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Shane C. Hage (May 15)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Mike Roetto (May 15)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started James Bliss (May 15)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Ron DuFresne (May 16)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Tobias Weisserth (May 13)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started fd (May 16)
- Re: Support the Sasser-author fund started Seth Alan Woolley (May 16)