BreachExchange mailing list archives
Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking
From: "Chris Walsh" <chris () cwalsh org>
Date: Thu, 17 Jul 2008 12:43:21 -0500
Agreed! To play the ever-popular security analogy game, if burglars can be deterred with mere signs saying "Premises protected by Acme Faultless Alarm Company", why not be happy if laptop thieves can be deterred by an actual product, albeit one which is not (and is not billed as) a panacea. Maybe the threat model that matters more is the one in which the hardware, not the data, is being targeted. In that case, measures to protect the hardware make sense. Of course, where the data are central -- as with controls against loss of PII -- a measure such as this would be inappropriate. Chris P.S. On the 'engraving' point, I can remember the police suggesting that one engrave ones SSN on items of high value and high portability, such as tools and bikes. Times have changed :^) On Thu, Jul 17, 2008 at 11:57 AM, Rosenquist, Matthew < matthew.rosenquist () intel com> wrote:
We may be missing the bigger point, as security is both technical as well as behavioral. Yes, it is obvious this technology in its current state can easily be undermined by a determined attacker. But will it be a deterrence? Will it affect the casual laptop theft? Will it give pause to people buying questionable laptops at the flea markets or from shady vendors? Will it make laptops less attractive targets to thieves looking for any means of a quick buck? Can it effect the resale economy of such 'hot' merchandise? Will it give employees a second thought about swiping extra equipment for personal use? Maybe. This technology increases the risk of being caught. If so, it will have an overall positive benefit. We all know an effective security program does not need to provide real security. We have locks on our home doors which are a joke to anyone who has the intention of getting into your house. But it does help. It thwarts opportunistic attacks where the thief is looking for the path of least resistance to reach their goals. If your house is locked and the next house is not, then there is a good chance your neighbor will be the one victimized. I see this technology, which could be evolved into something great eventually, as similar to engraving laptops with "Property of XXX company" or something obviously not easily resold or used in the open. It is a deterrent and lowers the target-attractiveness factor. I don't have any data handy, but last I read, most laptops are not stolen for their data. Rather it is a hardware itself which is valued.
_______________________________________________ Dataloss Mailing List (dataloss () attrition org) http://attrition.org/dataloss Tenable Network Security offers data leakage and compliance monitoring solutions for large and small networks. Scan your network and monitor your traffic to find the data needing protection before it leaks out! http://www.tenablesecurity.com/products/compliance.shtml
Current thread:
- Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking, (continued)
- Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Arshad Noor (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Davi Ottenheimer (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Davi Ottenheimer (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Allen (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Brian Krebs (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking lyger (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Max Hozven (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Brian Honan (Jul 17)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Rosenquist, Matthew (Jul 17)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Arshad Noor (Jul 17)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Chris Walsh (Jul 17)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Davi Ottenheimer (Jul 16)
- Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Arshad Noor (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Arshad Noor (Jul 16)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Eric K. Dickinson (Jul 17)
- Re: [ekmi] Re: fringe: Open source laptop tracking Stian Øvrevåge (Jul 17)