Re: Help understanding NMAP results

["forums () kentane net" <forums () kentane net>]

Theo
I have experienced something similar here. I am in South Africa, and we have a serious shortage of bandwidth here. 
Actually, it's just damn expensive. So what a lot of ISPs do is to have a transparent proxy. What I have seen from the 
ISP my previous company was using is that for every port scan that I did to my clients, port 80 was always open. It 
turns out that it was caused by a transparent proxy. This could be what you're experiencing

My 2c

Ciao

-------------------------
Original Message:
From: Theodore Wynnychenko <t-wynnychenko () northwestern edu>
To: security-basics () securityfocus com
Date: Thursday, July 7 2005 00:05
Subject: Help understanding NMAP results
Hello:

Well, hopefully this isn't too "stupid" a question to ask, but I have to ask
anyway.  I am nothing like a "computer security expert," (my job has nothing
to do with IT) but I have been playing with old computers and Linux in my
spare time (always learning).

Anyway, I have an old computer that runs LEAF LRP (linux kernel 2.4.27 or
so) as an external firewall to my home network.  This system basically uses
Shorewall to administer IPTABLES, and is set to default DROP any packets
comming in on the exernal NIC.

In the past, I did some basic port scans against myself using "online
scanners", and always got back information indicating that no ports were
responding (everything was "Stealth" - everything silently dropped).

So, while looking around, I came across NMAP, and decided to use it to scan
myself.  Went over to a friend's house, and ran an NMAP scan against myself
(nmap -sS -v -P0 -O xx.xx.xx.xx), and it says "Discovered open port
5190/tcp".

Now, this really confuses me.  When I scan myself using "online" scanners
(directed specifically at 5190), I get back that packets were
dropped/"stealthed," but NMAP says its open.  I added a specific rule (in
addition to the default drop policy) to drop anything to tcp 5190, but this
made no difference.  The "online" scanners still say nothing there, NMAP
still says its open.

NMAPs OS identification gives me several possibilities including "Linux
2.4.x|2.5.x," so NMAP does seem to be getting some imformation from the
firewall.

TCP 5190 is apparently related to AOL IM, but this is not something I have
ever used, and I can't think of any reason why the LEAF Firewall would have
it open.

What am I missing?

Thanks in advance for any help.

bye - ted