nanog mailing list archives

Re: Dodgy AS327933 ...?


From: Tom Beecher <beecher () beecher cc>
Date: Wed, 16 Aug 2023 09:49:48 -0400


That's a terrible excuse for the shitty concepts behind MikroTik's CLI.


Fear of being sued into oblivion by a massive corporation, even if they're
in the wrong, has influenced many choices in technology.

To be clear, I am not stating that Mikrotik made the CLI choices they did
BECAUSE of that concern. I have no knowledge there. I do know that Much
Larger Vendors have absolutely made tradeoffs because they didn't want to
deal with legal actions from Another Large Vendor or Patent Troll, so it's
not exactly uncommon.

On Tue, Aug 15, 2023 at 5:43 PM Chris Cappuccio <chris () nmedia net> wrote:

Tom Beecher [beecher () beecher cc] wrote:

It should be a huge embarrasment to the designers. They survive on low
price and unique features. It would be quite amazing to have a CLI
without
the nonsense.


That ship sailed years ago. Even though the legal precedent was set after
Cisco vs Arista that CLI elements that are of common , standard usage
aren't copyrightable, nobody wants to take the risk. So they come up with
other ways that tend to be not good.


That's a terrible excuse for the shitty concepts behind MikroTik's CLI.

I'm not saying my stuff is much better, but yeah, actually I am.


Current thread: