nanog mailing list archives
Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions
From: jim deleskie <deleskie () gmail com>
Date: Thu, 10 Mar 2022 11:34:58 -0400
I respect the people and goals here, but strongly echo Mel's statement. This is a much larger hammer then mail filtering lists. -jim On Thu, Mar 10, 2022, 11:26 AM Mel Beckman <mel () beckman org> wrote:
In my view, there is a core problematic statement in this document: “Military and propaganda agencies and their information infrastructure are potential targets of sanctions.” What is a “propaganda agency”. A political party? An incumbent candidate for re-election? The IRS? Anyone the “majority” disagrees with? Propaganda is in the eye of the beholder, and we’ve seen both sides of the political aisle sling this term in recent elections and legislative debates. I think it is a colossal mistake to weaponize the Internet. The potential for unintended consequences is huge, as is the potential for intended, politically-driven consequences -mel beckmanOn Mar 10, 2022, at 5:03 AM, Randy Bush <randy () psg com> wrote: maybe it is just that i am sufficiently anti-authoritarian that i try not to have the hubris to set myself up as the authority. maybe that in itself is hubris. as i was raised by someone who was a conscious objector in ww2, i can not bring myself to contribute to weapons etc. so i have donated to folk such as https://razomforukraine.org/ which is focused on medical support. randy
Current thread:
- The role of Internet governance in sanctions Bill Woodcock (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Randy Bush (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Bill Woodcock (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Randy Bush (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Mel Beckman (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions jim deleskie (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Michael Hallgren (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Bill Woodcock (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Mel Beckman (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Bill Woodcock (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Mel Beckman (Mar 10)
- RE: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Brandon Price (Mar 10)
- The role of Internet governance in sanctions Sylvain Baya (Mar 11)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Mel Beckman (Mar 11)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Bill Woodcock (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Randy Bush (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Tom Beecher (Mar 10)
- Re: The role of Internet governance in sanctions Mel Beckman (Mar 10)