nanog mailing list archives
Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices
From: Saku Ytti <saku () ytti fi>
Date: Thu, 13 Jan 2022 11:11:39 +0200
On Thu, 13 Jan 2022 at 00:31, Colton Conor <colton.conor () gmail com> wrote:
I agree it seems like MPLS is still the gold standard, but ideally I would only want to have costly, MPLS devices on the edge, only where needed. The core and transport devices I would love to be able to use generic IPv6 enabled switches, that don't need to support LDP. Low end switches from premium vendors, like Juniper's EX2200 - EX3400 don't support LDP for example.
It is utter fallacy that MPLS is costly, MPLS is systematically and fundamentally cheaper than IPv4 (and of course IPv6 costs more than IPv4). However if this doesn't reflect your day-to-day reality, then you can always do MPLSoGRE, so that core does not need more than IP. So in no scenario is this narrative justification for hiding MPLS headers inside IP headers, which is expensive and complex, systematically and fundamentally. -- ++ytti
Current thread:
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices, (continued)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Saku Ytti (Jan 12)
- RE: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices aaron1 (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Saku Ytti (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Sander Steffann (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Dale W. Carder (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Randy Bush (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Sander Steffann (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Saku Ytti (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Colton Conor (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Mark Tinka (Jan 12)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Saku Ytti (Jan 13)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Colton Conor (Jan 15)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices -> MPLS instead? Raymond Burkholder (Jan 15)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices -> MPLS instead? Mark Tinka (Jan 15)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices -> MPLS instead? scott (Jan 15)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Mark Tinka (Jan 15)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Jeff Tantsura (Jan 15)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Colton Conor (Jan 16)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Mark Tinka (Jan 16)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Brandon Butterworth (Jan 16)
- Re: SRv6 Capable NOS and Devices Saku Ytti (Jan 17)