nanog mailing list archives

Re: cheap MPLS router recommendations


From: Brandon Martin <lists.nanog () monmotha net>
Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 19:05:27 -0400

Most Arista boxes can do pretty much full MPLS (with appropriate honor-system licensing) as long as you don't need full-table Internet PE capabilities. At those bandwidths, you could easily get a used box off eBay and put it back under support (for more than you paid for the box) if you wanted to save some $$$.

Extreme SLX is essentially the same thing with a different badge and a different licensing structure.

An old Brocade (now Extreme) NetIron CER-4X (which is still supported and sold but nearing end of useful life for most providers) might even meet your needs. You wouldn't need the enhanced route scale hardware which makes them cheap on the secondary market. Avoid the CES even though it ostensibly does what you want. The MPLS signaling on this platform is probably a bit more mature but also perhaps lacking some modern niceties. Cost is probably not compelling if buying new, but IDK what they're actually selling them for these days.

Don't expect high-touch features like you might get from an ASR or MX, but if you just want to push/pop labels, signal L2/L3VPNs, participate in IGP with on-net routes, and move data around, they'll do the job with decent North-America facing sales and support facilities.

At those bandwidths and low port counts, you can also potentially use FRR or Quagga on Linux or *BSD on a suitably sized PC platform. Linux has usable MPLS support these days, though documentation is a bit lacking. One of the BSDs has had it longer and may be more thoroughly documented.
--
Brandon Martin


Current thread: