nanog mailing list archives
Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test
From: Mark Tinka <mark.tinka () seacom mu>
Date: Mon, 20 Apr 2020 17:39:18 +0200
On 20/Apr/20 17:31, Tom Beecher wrote:
( Speaking 100% for myself. ) I think it was tremendously irresponsible, especially in the context of current events, to take a complex technical issue like this and frame it to the general public as a 'safety' issue. It's created articles like this : https://www.wired.com/story/cloudflare-bgp-routing-safe-yet/ , which are terrible because they imply that RPKI is just some simple thing that anyone not doing is just lazy or stupid. Very few people will read to the bottom note about vendors implementing RPKI support, or do any other research on the issue and challenges that some companies face to do it. It's not their job; that's ours. I feel like there has been more momentum in getting more people to implement PKI in the last 18-24 months. ( Maybe others with different visibility have different opinions there. ) There are legitimate technical and business reasons why this isn't just a switch that can be turned on, and everyone in our industry knows that. In my opinion, Mr. Prince is doing a great disservice by taking this approach, and in the longer term RPKI adoption will likely be slower than it would have been otherwise. I genuinely appreciate much of what Cloudflare does for the sake of 'internet good' , but I believe they wildly missed the mark here.
The issue is that due to the democratization of information, every one is now an expert. So if we thought something only appealed to an obvious audience, think again. Mark.
Current thread:
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test, (continued)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Andrey Kostin (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Mark Tinka (Apr 21)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Andrey Kostin (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Mark Tinka (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Christopher Morrow (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Alex Band (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Christopher Morrow (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test jim deleskie (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Denys Fedoryshchenko (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Baldur Norddahl (Apr 20)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Alex Band (Apr 21)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Sander Steffann (Apr 21)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Baldur Norddahl (Apr 21)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Alex Band (Apr 21)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Matt Corallo via NANOG (Apr 21)
- Re: "Is BGP safe yet?" test Christopher Morrow (Apr 21)