nanog mailing list archives
Re: bad announcement taxonomy
From: Mattia Rossi <mattia.rossi.mailinglists () gmail com>
Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2015 14:50:14 +0100
Am 18.11.2015 um 13:08 schrieb William Herrin:
On Wed, Nov 18, 2015 at 6:51 AM, William Herrin <bill () herrin us> wrote:On Wed, Nov 18, 2015 at 5:06 AM, Randy Bush <randy () psg com> wrote:some friends and i were talking about recent routing cfs, and found we needed a clearer taxonomy. i throw this out. leak - i receive P and send it on to folk to whom i should not send it for business reasons (transit, peer, ...) mis-origination - i originate P when i do not own it hijack - an intentional mis-origination 7007 - i receive P (or some sub/superset), process it in some way (likely through my igp), and re-originate it, or part of it, as my own we need a name for 7007 other then vinniemis-origination. When you non-maliciously announce P as if you own it (even though you do not) the exact details of how you screwed the pooch are not externally important. And we have enough obscure names for things as it is.For that matter, just call it a hijack like it is. Don't legitimize originating a prefix you don't own by giving it an innocuous name.
So probably it should be structured like this: _________ leak /hijack ----------------- mis-origination (which should be better described as: I originate P when I don't have the right to)
\__________ origin scrubbing (I like that)It's a hijack (the result) in any case. If you want to differentiate between malice and stupidity/ignorance just call it "malicious hijack" opposed to "accidental hijack". And then list the cause (leak, mis-origination, origin scrubbing)
Cheers, Mat
Current thread:
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy, (continued)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Ken Matlock (Nov 19)
- RE: bad announcement taxonomy Baker, Byrn (Nov 20)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Jared Mauch (Nov 20)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy tim () pelican org (Nov 20)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Owen DeLong (Nov 20)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Arturo Servin (Nov 19)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Valdis . Kletnieks (Nov 19)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Randy Bush (Nov 19)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy William Herrin (Nov 18)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Mattia Rossi (Nov 18)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy William Herrin (Nov 18)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Roland Dobbins (Nov 18)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Stefan Fouant (Nov 18)
- Re: bad announcement taxonomy Randy Bush (Nov 19)