nanog mailing list archives
RE: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade?
From: "Nasser Heidari" <nasser () rasana net>
Date: Mon, 8 Jun 2015 10:46:32 +0430
On Sun, 7 Jun 2015, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:- If you are already using IPoE, tell more why should I upgrade?The IPoE and IPoEoADSL I have done didn't need radius, didn't need BNG,
didn't
need a lot of the complications you're talking about. It could basically
be realised in
any decent L3 switch as default gateway for the customers instead of
needing BNG.
So I'd say if you want to get full potential of IPoE you need to do
simplification as
well, otherwise there is little use in doing the work if he only thing you
want to
change is from IPoPPPoE to IPoE encapsulation and keep all the other stuff
you're
doing. IPoPPPoE requires special CPE and router at your end to achieve high
speeds,
because they need to support encapsulation/decapsulation of packets at
whatever
speed you provide. The number of devices that do this is a lot smaller
than the
ones that do decent speeds with just IPoE. So some people will say migrating to IPoE from IPoPPPoE buys them nothing, because they feel they need all the mechanisms they currently use. Greenfield deployments might say "hey, we can do this without a lot of the
needed
mechanisms for IPoPPPoE" and save a lot of money and complication. -- Mikael Abrahamsson email: swmike () swm pp se
Thanks for your reply. I'm would like this simplicity if I could keep same functionalities I have in PPPoE. By functionalities I mean: - AAA - Triple-ply services and classified accounting per service - Possibility to suspend a user service in case of over-quota - applying fair-share policies Do I have any option to have simplicity and same functionality together? Regards, Nasser
Attachment:
smime.p7s
Description:
Current thread:
- PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Nasser Heidari (Jun 06)
- Re: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Mikael Abrahamsson (Jun 07)
- RE: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Nasser Heidari (Jun 07)
- RE: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Mikael Abrahamsson (Jun 07)
- Re: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Colton Conor (Jun 08)
- Re: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Scott Helms (Jun 08)
- RE: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Nasser Heidari (Jun 07)
- Re: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Mikael Abrahamsson (Jun 07)
- Re: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Eduardo Schoedler (Jun 09)
- Re: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Sabri Berisha (Jun 10)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- RE: PPPoE/IPoE, any recommendations for upgrade? Murat Kaipov (Jun 07)