nanog mailing list archives
Re: Charter ARP Leak
From: Chris Boyd <cboyd () gizmopartners com>
Date: Mon, 29 Dec 2014 12:05:33 -0600
On Dec 29, 2014, at 11:51 AM, Jay Ashworth <jra () baylink com> wrote: Ok. But the interface to which the cablemodem is attached, in the general single-DHCP-IP case, is a /24, is it not?
No, I've seen multiple IPv4 /21s assigned to a single customer interface on a CMTS. The newer CMTS are beastly large boxes.
The example Valdis posted had 5 or 6 different /24s from all over the v4 address space; that seems exceptionally sloppy routing...
It's just the nature of having multiple secondary IP addresses on the same RF interface facing the customers
I have seen ARP-traffic-not-for-me come through a cablemodem in the past as well, but it was *uniformly* for the /24 in which my modem's address lived that day.
Cable modems are typically bridges (at least the ones that Work Right, IMHO), so it makes sense that you'll see all layer 2 broadcasts. If you live in a small enough town, or have business class service on your modem, you may only see a smaller or single subnet. On the residential side in a larger town you'll see lots of layer 2 stuff. --Chris
Current thread:
- Re: Charter ARP Leak, (continued)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Rampley Jr, Jim F (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Jay Ashworth (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Brett Frankenberger (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Jay Ashworth (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak David Coulson (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Jay Ashworth (Dec 29)
- RE: Charter ARP Leak Corey Touchet (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Ricky Beam (Dec 29)
- RE: Charter ARP Leak Phil Bedard (Dec 29)
- Message not available
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Larry Sheldon (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Rampley Jr, Jim F (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Chris Boyd (Dec 29)
- RE: Charter ARP Leak Phil Bedard (Dec 29)
- Message not available
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Larry Sheldon (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Jason Hellenthal (Dec 29)
- Re: Charter ARP Leak Jared Mauch (Dec 29)