nanog mailing list archives
Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives?
From: "Mukom Akong T." <mukom.tamon () gmail com>
Date: Thu, 7 Mar 2013 13:50:24 +0400
On Thu, Mar 7, 2013 at 12:25 AM, William Herrin <bill () herrin us> wrote:
For that, you need the help of a real cost analyst. That's what they're for; they help organizations figure out a solid idea what something will really cost before they start spending money. If your organization is large, you may even have one on staff somewhere.
Point taken. Thank you.
Implicitly they'll also be looking for the answer to a fourth question: Do you know WTF you're talking about? If you assure them it's all peaches and cream with tiny costs and no opportunity cost, the answer is, "no."I believe if anyone who can phrase the "IPv4 Exhaustion Problem + IPv6 Solution" in very specific terms of the business model of the companywillimplicitly inspire confidence in execs that they know what they aretalkingabout.Your first paragraph loses the argument: the day has past when IPv6 could become a credible solution to the IPv4 exhaustion problem. Like it or lump it, NAT was the solution to the IPv4 exhaustion problem. Which the exec will learn when he chats up his computer literate buddy before making his decision.
I don't think NAT solves the problem in a sustainable way. Sure for managers that are already driven by short-term goals, that's fine however in Africa, we are seeing situations where NAT just doesn't scale. Specifically with the influx of submarine cables, the bottleneck has shifted from 'available bandwidth' to 'NAT' (or strictly speaking NAPT) capacity.
If you're an ISP or you make network software, this is a straightforward case to make. There are public sources of IPv6 deployment rate data. You can presume that a similar rate holds among your customers and that the customers who deploy IPv6 will disqualify your product if the product doesn't work with IPv6.
Good point.
If your business isn't networks, you have a much harder case to make. As another poster noted, the end of IPv4 is not on the radar yet. A statistically insignificant number of people will change banks this year over their bank's web site IPv6 reachability.
Thank you once again.
Regards, Bill Herrin -- William D. Herrin ................ herrin () dirtside com bill () herrin us 3005 Crane Dr. ...................... Web: <http://bill.herrin.us/> Falls Church, VA 22042-3004
-- Mukom Akong T. http://about.me/perfexcellence | twitter: @perfexcellent ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ “When you work, you are the FLUTE through whose lungs the whispering of the hours turns to MUSIC" - Kahlil Gibran -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Current thread:
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives?, (continued)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? William Herrin (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Mukom Akong T. (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Mukom Akong T. (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Antonio Querubin (Mar 06)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Mukom Akong T. (Mar 06)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Antonio Querubin (Mar 07)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Mukom Akong T. (Mar 07)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Mukom Akong T. (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? William Herrin (Mar 06)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Mukom Akong T. (Mar 07)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Mukom Akong T. (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Cameron Byrne (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? John Curran (Mar 06)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Owen DeLong (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Matthew Kaufman (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Owen DeLong (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Matthew Kaufman (Mar 05)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Owen DeLong (Mar 06)
- Re: What Should an Engineer Address when 'Selling' IPv6 to Executives? Cameron Byrne (Mar 06)