RE: subrate SFP?

[Jamie Bowden <jamie () photon com>]

> From: Saku Ytti [mailto:saku () ytti fi]


> I got quite a bit of replies from sellers selling me cuSFP, insisting they
> work.
>
> So I'd like to clear up on this. For 10/100 to work on SFP slot, the PHY in
> the host needs to be multirate. Exception is SGMII which supposedly
> supports magic mode where SFP can ask it to send same bit 10 times, then
> SFP can discard 9/10 bits, to remain very dumb yet deliver 100M client on
> 1GE host.
>
> RGMII does not support this trick and this trick does not bring you down to
> 10M. One box that we have right now, which can't do any of this is ME-4924.
>
> There is absolutely no reason that you couldn't deliver 'media converter'
> or '2 port switch' in a SFP casing, to get that 1 10/100 port in every
> 4500-X or EX4550 port you need to cater some legacy. If my desire is odd (2
> people have expressed off list they want same) this won't be built. But if
> this is somewhat common demand and missing product, we can certainly get
> such SFP built.
>
> Obviously this SFP would cost bit more than normal cuSFP, as it needs to do
> rudimentary buffering, packet dropping and it needs to have frame parser.

Considering that Dell and HP at least are shipping brand new hardware with IPMI/BMC/iLO/whatever management ports that 
can only speak 100mbit when every other Ethernet interface in the box at least gigabit, having a useful way to talk to 
that port without having to keep separate switching hardware around would be nice.  I'm not holding my breath, but you 
know, along with a pony, this would be nice.

Jamie