nanog mailing list archives
Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration
From: Cameron Byrne <cb.list6 () gmail com>
Date: Mon, 26 Nov 2012 07:36:22 -0800
Sent from ipv6-only Android On Nov 26, 2012 5:54 AM, "Dobbins, Roland" <rdobbins () arbor net> wrote:
On Nov 26, 2012, at 8:33 PM, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:Why is that a significant question?It is significant because it provides some rough measure of the relative
*importance* of IPv6 connectivity to the users and to the content/app/services networks.
Ipv6 is not important for users, it is important for network operators who want to sustain their business.
We are not yet at the point where ordinary people need end-to-end IPv6
connectivity across the public Internet in order to do their jobs.
We are not even at the point where ordinary people need end-to-end IPv6
connectivity across the public Internet for recreational purposes.
Providing IPv6 capabilities for popular content/apps/services like
Google, Netflix, and Facebook is one thing. Creating compelling content/apps/services which are *only* accessible via IPv6 is another.
Dont hold your breath. It wont happen, and in the end means nothing.
I believe gaming developers are probably in the best position to provide
such a stimulus, should they determine that it makes economic sense for them to do so.
Nope. Nobody will leave money on the table by alienating users.
If they have IPv6, they will access a significant amount of content via
IPv6.
The definition of 'have IPv6' is somewhat nebulous, at present - that's
part of the problem.
Apple and msft os' s now make a clear judgement on that. So, you need to update your perspective.
I don't get why people are arguing that we shouldn't do IPv6 because
IPv6 is so little of total traffic.
I'm not making that argument.
Good.
There is so little traffic because ISPs do not turn on IPv6. The
content is there now.
As Randy noted, some big destination networks have in fact enabled IPv6
connectivity to their properties. A lot haven't, however, and user application capabilities/behaviors also come into play.
Again, where're the compelling IPv6-only content/apps/services?
Does not matter. And it will not happen. The better question, for an isp, is what kind of ipv4 secondary market budget do you have? How hot is your cgn running? Like ALGs much ? Security and attribute much ? Again , users dont care or know about v4 or v6. This is purely a network operator and app issue (cough cough ... skype). CB
----------------------------------------------------------------------- Roland Dobbins <rdobbins () arbor net> // <http://www.arbornetworks.com> Luck is the residue of opportunity and design. -- John Milton
Current thread:
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration, (continued)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Dobbins, Roland (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Mikael Abrahamsson (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Dobbins, Roland (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Damian Menscher (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Eugen Leitl (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration sthaug (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Sander Steffann (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Marco Davids (Prive) (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Owen DeLong (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Mikael Abrahamsson (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Cameron Byrne (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Dobbins, Roland (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Cameron Byrne (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Richard Barnes (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Randy Bush (Nov 27)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Dobbins, Roland (Nov 26)
- RE: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Tony Hain (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Dobbins, Roland (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Michael Thomas (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Dobbins, Roland (Nov 26)
- Re: Big day for IPv6 - 1% native penetration Michael Thomas (Nov 26)