nanog mailing list archives
Re: SP's and v4 block assignments
From: Owen DeLong <owen () delong com>
Date: Fri, 18 Mar 2011 15:49:01 -0700
On Mar 18, 2011, at 2:11 PM, Jeroen van Aart wrote:
Owen DeLong wrote:I'll point out that Comcast charges $5/month for a static IP on their business circuits.I get charged $6 for a static IP for a home internet connection (not a business account). Although in the Netherlands xs4all will give you one for free, so it depends.
In the US, Comcast won't give you a static on a home connection. You have to subscribe to business class service to get a static IP.
I am wondering though, is it normal to charge around $5/month for rDNS on that IP? I'd say a one time fee for the effort of adding the record to the nameserver would be enough. But then maybe the consumer ISP gets charged by their ISP for rDNS.
I've never had anyone charge me for hosting DNS or providing rDNS, but, I haven't needed anyone else to do that for me in so long that I have no idea what is standard now.
This is not uncommon practice. I agree with you that it's undesirable, but, it's not uncommon among the access networks.I guess it's ok to expect a small fee when your consumer grade internet connection gets a static IP. Given that many large ISPs force you to get a business account if you want a static IP, and a higher price.
I think both practices are relatively despicable, but, widespread enough that perhaps I am in the minority. Hopefully this will get better in IPv6. Owen
Current thread:
- SP's and v4 block assignments Andrew Elliott (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Patrick W. Gilmore (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Andrew Elliott (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Owen DeLong (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Jon Lewis (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Patrick W. Gilmore (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Leo Bicknell (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Andrew Elliott (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Owen DeLong (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Jeroen van Aart (Mar 18)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Owen DeLong (Mar 18)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments TR Shaw (Mar 18)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Owen DeLong (Mar 19)
- RE: SP's and v4 block assignments Nathan Eisenberg (Mar 19)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Jeff Wheeler (Mar 19)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Owen DeLong (Mar 20)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Jeff Wheeler (Mar 20)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Patrick W. Gilmore (Mar 15)
- Re: SP's and v4 block assignments Jon Lewis (Mar 18)