nanog mailing list archives
Re: riverbed steelhead
From: Andrey Khomyakov <khomyakov.andrey () gmail com>
Date: Mon, 25 Apr 2011 13:55:15 -0400
I personally would take Riverbed over Cisco for one main reason that I have discovered when I was researching them (that was good 3-4 years ago and cisco may have "improved" since). Cisco "accelerates" based on application. That is to say if it's not a well known application protocol, they do not do anything with it. So, they are probably good for HTTP/FTP/Samba etc. Riverbed does not care for applications (they still support application based acceleration, but they also support non standard stuff). They take something along the lines of data hashes and store them (along with data of course). They just store raw bytes as opposed to a let's say a file. That played out well when I had to make a decision about which brand to purchase for the company that had a homegrown application. So in a nutshell, Riverbed improved performance of that application (as well as all the standard players like HTTP/FTP etc), while cicso said outright that they won't. After purchase, we saw a dramatic improvement in "user experience" (basically the complaints stopped) from our EU site that was accessing windows (samba) based file servers in USA. Those guys at the time were connected to the US office over MLPPP (4 T1s). Samba sucked for them along with everything else. The only issue I had with Riverbed is their licensing model feels very backwards. It took me a while to understand what we needed. Andrey On Thu, Apr 21, 2011 at 10:36 PM, Jonathan Fernatt <fernattj () gmail com>wrote:
On Thu, Apr 21, 2011 at 2:49 PM, harbor235 <harbor235 () gmail com> wrote:Anyone out there have experience with Riverbed Steelhead products? Do they improve TCP performance over WAN links? is it worth the price? mikeI've had good experiences with both Riverbed Steelhead and Cisco WAAS products. Both have a very short ROI. I think either are well worth the price. Jon
-- Andrey Khomyakov [khomyakov.andrey () gmail com]
Current thread:
- riverbed steelhead harbor235 (Apr 21)
- RE: riverbed steelhead Stefan Fouant (Apr 21)
- RE: riverbed steelhead Stefan Fouant (Apr 21)
- RE: riverbed steelhead Stephens, Josh (Apr 21)
- Re: riverbed steelhead Joel Maslak (Apr 21)
- Re: riverbed steelhead Jonathan Fernatt (Apr 21)
- Re: riverbed steelhead Andrey Khomyakov (Apr 25)
- Re: riverbed steelhead James Michael Keller (Apr 25)
- Re: riverbed steelhead Eric Cables (Apr 25)
- Re: riverbed steelhead Andrey Khomyakov (Apr 25)
- RE: riverbed steelhead Stefan Fouant (Apr 21)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: riverbed steelhead Elijah Savage (Apr 27)