nanog mailing list archives
Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? )
From: William Herrin <bill () herrin us>
Date: Tue, 12 Apr 2011 09:47:35 -0400
On Tue, Apr 12, 2011 at 2:49 AM, Tim Chown <tjc () ecs soton ac uk> wrote:
Well indeed, top-posting is just so much more efficient given the volumes of email most of us probably see each day.
That's true... if you're adding a trivial thought to an already concise thread. If you're adding complex argument or information, or if the thread has wandered into a wide topic, a top-posted message is often incomprehensible. Without the context provided by posting inline, the reader can't immediately tell what point or points you're responding to. That's why in lists like this one we intermix new thoughts with the information they're responsive to. More, bottom-posting is just a subset of inline posting in which we're only responding to one element.
But I'm afraid times have changed; bottom-posted email is now an annoyance to most just as a slow-loading web page would be.
Then you're doing it wrong. You're supposed to trim the original down to just the context that clarifies your response. That's the other problem with top-posters... nobody trims, so if I want to understand what they're attempting to say I have to scroll down, read all the previous messages and then guess which part they're replying to. Usually the lazy top-poster hasn't said anything worth that much effort. Regards, Bill Herrin -- William D. Herrin ................ herrin () dirtside comĀ bill () herrin us 3005 Crane Dr. ...................... Web: <http://bill.herrin.us/> Falls Church, VA 22042-3004
Current thread:
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ), (continued)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) Valdis . Kletnieks (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) Michael DeMan (Apr 11)
- Message not available
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) Tim Chown (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) Michael DeMan (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) Mikael Abrahamsson (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) gord (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) D'Arcy J.M. Cain (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) gord (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: AnySuggestions as to anAlternative? ) Michael Painter (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) D'Arcy J.M. Cain (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) William Herrin (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) JC Dill (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) Valdis . Kletnieks (Apr 12)
- Re: Top-posting (was: Barracuda Networks is at it again: Any Suggestions as to anAlternative? ) Jay Ashworth (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting Daniel Staal (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting Jay Ashworth (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting bmanning (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting Owen DeLong (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting Richard Golodner (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting Bryan Fields (Apr 11)
- Re: Top-posting Bret Palsson (Apr 11)