nanog mailing list archives
Re: Mikrotik BGP Question
From: Martin List-Petersen <martin () airwire ie>
Date: Fri, 21 May 2010 22:56:11 +0100
On 21/05/10 13:39, Bret Clark wrote:
On 05/21/2010 08:23 AM, Nick Hilliard wrote:I will refrain from making any smart-ass comments about Mikrotik and BGP, but no: there is no reason whatever that you can't take your internet feeds from different locations, so long as you have a good quality interior network link between those two locations, and your two routers talk iBGP to each other. Just make sure your boxes have enough RAM to cope with a full dfz feed. I.e. it's just the same as using any other router in this regard. NickI've used Mikrotiks for everything except BGP, but we don't use Mikrotiks for BGP only because we already had BGP on a different platform...personally, when it comes to BGP, I think people are better off running it on devices they are familiar with rather then trying to learn the idiosyncrasies of a new platform.
While Mikrotik's BGP implementation isn't very sofisticated, there is no reason, why you can't have your feeds in different places. As Nick outlined, you need to set iBGP up between the boxes. I'm running myself a ISP on mainly Mikrotik basis (basestations and clients, approx 2500 users) and I've been extensively testing Mikrotik's BGP stack in the last 4 years (from 2.9 and up). Mikrotik wrote the whole routing stack from scratch in 3.x, which resultet in tons of problems and bugs. In my opinion, it still isn't where it should be. Don't get me wrong, but there are several pitfalls. - Mikrotik still has some memory leaks in the BGP stack somewhere, causing funny issues at times. - Filters aren't adequate for my use, and lacking a lot on IPv4, but even more on IPv4. First of all, you will need at least a RB1000, RB1100 or a PC based Mikrotik router to get enough ram, to accomodate one full-table or more. Anything less and you can forget it. I'm running a mix of Quagga boxes, Cisco and recently Juniper instead for BGP. For our internal routing OSPF on Mikrotik definatly does the job. Just my 2c. Kind regards, Martin List-Petersen -- Airwire - Ag Nascadh Pobail an Iarthair http://www.airwire.ie Phone: 091-865 968
Current thread:
- Mikrotik BGP Question Lorell Hathcock (May 21)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question Nick Hilliard (May 21)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question Bret Clark (May 21)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question Martin List-Petersen (May 21)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question Graham Beneke (May 22)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question Allan Eising (May 24)
- RE: Mikrotik BGP Question Dennis Burgess (May 24)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question Martin List-Petersen (May 25)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question Bret Clark (May 21)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question Nick Hilliard (May 21)
- Re: Mikrotik BGP Question joel jaeggli (May 21)
- RE: Mikrotik BGP Question Lorell Hathcock (May 22)
- RE: Mikrotik BGP Question Ingo Flaschberger (May 22)