nanog mailing list archives

Bad Support Bots (was: SORBS on autopilot?)


From: Michael Thomas <mike () mtcc com>
Date: Fri, 15 Jan 2010 08:57:28 -0800

William Hamilton wrote:
"Please reply to this message to reopen your ticket and escalate your case to a live human being."

And now SORBS:

"If you feel otherwise, please reply to this message
to re-open your ticket."

Try as I might I really can't see what is not clear here...

The difference is that nobody wants to "talk" to a robot when they're the victim of a false positive which is causing business impacting interruption. A robot is not empowered to go beyond its instructions, and if it's programmed either wrong or with
inadequate nuance, there is no escalation.

Let's not forget that IVR mazes and their modern day counterparts have been built in large part not to resolve problems but to reduce the cost of "support" by expensive human automatons to the point that it's often incidental if they actually solve problems. This is not a well kept secret, and when you're trapped by one especially when it's produced a crisis,
its rather disingenuous and maddening for the IVR's keeper to cop attitude.

A much better approach -- assuming that the goal is actually to resolve problems rather than shield resources -- is to at least make the escalation process transparent. Knowing what you have to do in order to get ahold of some of something empowered to resolve problems is a
lot better than a robot telling you to take the next turn in a twisty maze.


Mike, this is hardly SORBS specific lest anybody be confused


Current thread: