nanog mailing list archives
Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL
From: Arie Vayner <arievayner () gmail com>
Date: Fri, 15 May 2009 21:34:06 +0300
David, My 1st advice would be to look also at the other features/capabilities you require, and not just at "feeds and speeds". Some examples for functionality could be: - QOS - NetFlow - DDoS resistance In general the 6500 and the 12000 are hardware based platforms, with the 12000 being more distributed in nature, using linecard resources for data plane (6500 does it too if you have DFC installed). 7200 is a CPU/software based platform, so the same processor does packet forwarding and control plane processing. The 6500 (depends on specific module selection) is more restricted with QOS and NetFlow functionality as it is designed to do very fast forwarding at a relativly cheaper price. The 12000 has everything implemented in hardware, and depends on the engine types (don't use anything other than Eng 3 or 5) has all the support you may dream of for things like QOS and other features. The 7200 is a software based router, which means that it support any feature you may ever dream of, but the scalability decreases as you turn them on. Another option you should consider seriously should be the ASR1000 router, which is a newer platform and has a new architecture. All its features are based on hardware support, and it could actually prove the best choice for what you need. The ASR1002 comes with 4 integrated 1GE ports, which could be all that you would ever need (but it has quite a few extension slots left). Arie On Fri, May 15, 2009 at 6:07 PM, David Storandt <dstorandt () teljet com>wrote:
We're stuck in an engineering pickle, so some experience from this crew would be useful in tie-breaking... We operate a business-grade FTTx ISP with ~75 customers and 800Mbps of Internet traffic, currently using 6509/Sup2s for core routing and port aggregation. The MSFC2s are under stress from 3x full route feeds, pared down to 85% to fit the TCAM tables. One system has a FlexWAN with an OC3 card and it's crushing the CPU on the MSFC2. System tuning (stable IOS and esp. disabling SPD) helped a lot but still doesn't have the power to pull through. Hardware upgrades are needed... We need true full routes and more CPU horsepower for crunching BGP (+12 smaller peers + ISIS). OC3 interfaces are going to be mandatory, one each at two locations. Oh yeah, we're still a larger startup without endless pockets. Power, rack space, and SmartNet are not concerns at any location (on-site cold spares). We may need an upstream OC12 in the future but that's a ways out and not a concern here. Our engineering team has settled on three $20k/node options: - Sup720-3BXLs with PS and fan upgrades - Sup2s as switches + ISIS + statics and no BGP, push BGP edge routing off to NPE-G2s across a 2-3Gbps port-channel - Sup2s as switches + ISIS + statics and no BGP, push BGP edge routing off to a 12008 with E3 engines across a 2-3Gbps port-channel. Ideas and constructive opinions welcome, especially software and stability-related. Many thanks, -Dave
Current thread:
- NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL David Storandt (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Elmar K. Bins (May 15)
- RE: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Paul Stewart (May 15)
- RE: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Leland E. Vandervort (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Aaron Millisor (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Alex H. Ryu (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL David Storandt (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Brian Feeny (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Aaron Millisor (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Alex H. Ryu (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Arie Vayner (May 15)
- RE: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Crooks, Sam (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Adam Armstrong (May 18)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Steve Dalberg (May 18)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Julio Arruda (May 18)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Adam Armstrong (May 21)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Steve Dalberg (May 18)
- RE: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Holmes,David A (May 18)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Adam LaFountain (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL David Storandt (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Valdis . Kletnieks (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL Leo Bicknell (May 15)
- Re: NPE-G2 vs. Sup720-3BXL David Storandt (May 15)