nanog mailing list archives
Re: breadcrumbs and collusion
From: Dave Howe <DaveHowe () gmx co uk>
Date: Sat, 27 Sep 2008 12:26:01 +0100
Laurence F. Sheldon, Jr. wrote:
michael.dillon () bt com wrote:However, it makes little sense to close your gate to keep the stray dogs out of your yard, if they can just come in via your neighbour's gate and climb over the fences.It makes a lot of sense. Having closed your gate, and discovered a stray dog in your back yard, you can call the animal control people and they stand a good chance of catching that stray dog.Like most NANAE ...eerrr...NANOG metaphors this one is broken.
Well, the first draft had "junkies" rather than dogs, but I decided that would cause issues in itself. Cats might be a better analogy though, you can train a dog to know better....
We are not talking about stray dogs, were are talking about bad behaviour.
Indeed so. unlike a stray dog, one that gets into your yard doesn't just crap there, but all over the neighbourhood, leaving clear trails that lead back to you.
If I keep them from dealing that stuff in my parking lot I do several things, in approximate priority order: My clean customers don't have to suffer any effects of the bad guys being on my lot.
surely, but they still get dog crap on their boots
The bad guys learn it is not a good place to try to deal.
They don't care. as long as they can get into your community *somewhere* that is good enough, it doesn't matter to them where.
The Law knows one place they don't have to worry about.
true, but the discussion wasn't regarding *not* keeping your yard clean, but was regarding warning your neighbours so *they* can keep their yard clean - and that there is a self-benefit (in that some of the dirt in your yard comes from any dogs allowed into theirs) that would make it reasonable to do so (and not unfair victimization of stray dogs) and any suggestion that the Law would trust, just because you booted out *one* set of dogs, that your yard would forever more remain clean, confuses me. Perhaps you could explain further?
Current thread:
- Where to move the Intercage/Atrivo discussion (was: the Intercage mess), (continued)
- Where to move the Intercage/Atrivo discussion (was: the Intercage mess) Justin Shore (Sep 25)
- Re: Where to move the Intercage/Atrivo discussion Laurence F. Sheldon, Jr. (Sep 25)
- Re: Where to move the Intercage/Atrivo discussion (was: the Intercage mess) Valdis . Kletnieks (Sep 25)
- Re: Where to move the Intercage/Atrivo discussion (was: the Intercage mess) Christopher Morrow (Sep 25)
- Re: Where to move the Intercage/Atrivo discussion (was: the Intercage mess) J. Oquendo (Sep 25)
- breadcrumbs and collusion bmanning (Sep 25)
- Re: breadcrumbs and collusion Dave Howe (Sep 25)
- RE: breadcrumbs and collusion michael.dillon (Sep 26)
- Re: breadcrumbs and collusion Laurence F. Sheldon, Jr. (Sep 26)
- Re: breadcrumbs and collusion Roy (Sep 26)
- Re: breadcrumbs and collusion Dave Howe (Sep 27)
- Re: breadcrumbs and collusion Dave Howe (Sep 28)
- RE: breadcrumbs and collusion michael.dillon (Sep 29)
- Re: breadcrumbs and collusion J. Oquendo (Sep 25)
- Re: Where to move the Intercage/Atrivo discussion (was: the Intercage mess) Valdis . Kletnieks (Sep 25)
- carpet sellers bmanning (Sep 25)