nanog mailing list archives
Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos
From: John Curran <jcurran () mail com>
Date: Mon, 3 Sep 2007 23:21:38 -0400
At 7:40 PM -0700 9/3/07, Joel Jaeggli wrote:
John Curran wrote:At 9:21 PM -0400 9/3/07, Joe Abley wrote:Is there a groundswell of *operators* who think TCP should be replaced, and believe it can be replaced?Just imagine *that* switchover, with the same level of transition planning as we received with IPv6... ;-)The congestion control mechanism can be replaced independent of the transport. In point of fact linux systems have been using bic-tcp by default since 2004 and nobody noticed...
Backwards compatibility is "a good thing" (and what was not a achieved in the IPv6 case despite repeated claims to the contrary...) /John p.s. bic-tcp (and cubic) certainly have been noticed... "We first examined the scenario in which a long-lived Standard TCP and a high-speed transport protocol flow coexist. We observed the well- known unfairness problem: that is, a highspeed transport protocol flow starved the long-lived Standard TCP flow for bandwidth, ..." (K. Kumazoe, K. Kouyama, Y. Hori, M. Tsuru, Y. Oie, "Can highspeed transport protocols be deployed on the Internet? : Evaluation through experiments on JGNII", PFLDnet 2006, Nara, Japan.) We really don't know how well windows hosts (or Vista hosts with CTCP) actually perform on a shared network of bic-tcp systems.
Current thread:
- Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos nanditad (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Joe Abley (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos John Curran (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Joel Jaeggli (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos John Curran (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos bmanning (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Mark Smith (Sep 05)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos John Curran (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Joe Abley (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Steven M. Bellovin (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Sean Donelan (Sep 03)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Tony Finch (Sep 04)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Stephen Stuart (Sep 04)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Tony Finch (Sep 04)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call forDemos Christian Kuhtz (Sep 04)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Sean Donelan (Sep 04)
- Re: Congestion control train-wreck workshop at Stanford: Call for Demos Stephen Stuart (Sep 05)