nanog mailing list archives
Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong!
From: "Paul G" <paul () rusko us>
Date: Mon, 17 Jan 2005 01:39:49 -0500
----- Original Message ----- From: "Steven J. Sobol" <sjsobol () JustThe net> To: "Jim Shankland" <nanog () shankland org> Cc: "Adrian Chadd" <adrian () creative net au>; <nanog () merit edu> Sent: Monday, January 17, 2005 1:33 AM Subject: Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong!
On Sun, 16 Jan 2005, Jim Shankland wrote:Of course it's unreasonable to expect a registrar to have to put up with such a burden during off hours: God only knows what kind of silly calls would come in. "Emergencies" are best handled in a batch during the regular work week. For the stuff that really won't wait, you just put a lawyer on retainer, who can fax off a letter telling the complainant to sod off until Monday morning, or until the moon is in the seventh house and Jupiter aligns with Mars, whichever comes first. I mean, if we can't be on the golf course by 3:00, what are we in this business for, anyway -- right?The registrar DOES need to define "Emergency." "Emergency" does not mean "page on-call staffers because I forgot to renew my domain and it's fallen out of the roots, and Customer Service is closed Saturday." Such an event is defined as being "My Own Fault, Not Due to Catastrophic Conditions" and doesn't warrant bugging the person on-call. As long as the registrar defines what constitutes a page-able emergency, they should be ok. (Or is this overly simplistic?)
ime, the act of defining 'emergency' does not provoke compliance therewith. -p --- paul galynin
Current thread:
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Eric Brunner-Williams in Portland Maine (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Joe Maimon (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Perry E. Metzger (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Chris Adams (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Adrian Chadd (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Steve Sobol (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Jim Shankland (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Steven J. Sobol (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Paul G (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Steve Sobol (Jan 19)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Perry E. Metzger (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Joe Maimon (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Alexei Roudnev (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Christopher L. Morrow (Jan 16)
- Re: The entire mechanism is Wrong! Richard Cox (Jan 17)
- Standard of Promptness William Allen Simpson (Jan 17)
- Re: Standard of Promptness Eric Brunner-Williams in Portland Maine (Jan 18)
- Re: Standard of Promptness John Curran (Jan 18)
- RE: Standard of Promptness David Schwartz (Jan 18)
- RE: Standard of Promptness Tim Wilde (Jan 18)