nanog mailing list archives
Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer?
From: Bill Woodcock <woody () pch net>
Date: Wed, 1 Sep 2004 15:59:35 -0700 (PDT)
On Wed, 1 Sep 2004, James wrote: >> Hmm, why not anycast the service/application ips? Having >> inconsistent DNS info seems like a problem waiting to bite your >> behind. > Which begs the question.. is anyone doing this right now? Yes, lots of people. Akamai is the largest provider of services based on inconsistent DNS that I know of, and they've been doing it for quite a while. They were by no means a pioneer. Many others before them, they might just be one you've heard of. > I've been wondering about the potential issues wrt anycasting tcp > applications. TCP sessions would be affected negatively during a > route change. Yup, which happens about one hundredth as often as TCP sessions being dropped for other reasons, so it's not worth worrying about. You'll never measure it, unless your network is already too unstable to carry TCP flows anyway. This is also ancient history. I and I assume plenty of other people were doing this with long-lived FTP sessions prior to the advent of the World Wide Web. This is the objection clever people who don't actually bother to try it normally come up with, after they've thought about it for a few (but fewer than, say, ten) minutes. -Bill
Current thread:
- DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Steve Francis (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Bill Woodcock (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Steve Francis (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Christopher L. Morrow (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Steve Francis (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Christopher L. Morrow (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? James (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Christopher L. Morrow (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Bill Woodcock (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Steve Francis (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Paul Vixie (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Steve Francis (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Christopher L. Morrow (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Bill Woodcock (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Patrick W Gilmore (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Bill Woodcock (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Steve Francis (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Duane Wessels (Sep 01)
- Re: DNS Anycast as traffic optimizer? Paul Jakma (Sep 01)