nanog mailing list archives
Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA
From: jlewis () lewis org
Date: Mon, 17 Mar 2003 09:42:03 -0500 (EST)
On Mon, 17 Mar 2003, Leo Bicknell wrote:
Just like the people who get 69/8 blocks should expect them to be fully usable as well, right? Surely if one reserved /24 means you can return space and get new space assigned then the inability to reach some percentage of the internet is an even bigger, and more immediate concern that should warrant the same treatment.
I think all that really needs to happen here is an RFC update that unreserves 223.255.255.0/24. RFC3330 already mentioned that the basis for this reservation was no longer applicable. Someone at IANA just screwed up the order of events, as the block should have been explicitly unreserved before it was assigned. On the same note, if you do a few google/groups.google.com searches, you'll find that LOTS of people treat the networks marked as IANA-Reserved in http://www.iana.org/assignments/ipv4-address-space in much the same way as RFC1918 space, some even call them quasi-RFC1918 space. A groups.google.com search for 69.0.0.0/8 will turn up 5 pages of hits, nearly all of which are firewall/ipf/ipchains/etc. config examples recommending and demonstrating how to block, among other reserved nets, 69.0.0.0/8. I'd like to strongly encourage IANA to reexamine all current IANA-Reserved blocks, decide which ones will remain Reserved for the forseeable future, and which are likely candidates for assignment to RIRs at any future date, and update these to a more suggestive status such as Future-RIR-Assignment. Otherwise, we're going to repeat the 69/8 exercise (signifigant parts of the net ignoring the space months after assignment...some parts ignoring it likely for years) every time a net goes from being IANA-Reserved to assigned to some RIR. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Jon Lewis *jlewis () lewis org*| I route System Administrator | therefore you are Atlantic Net | _________ http://www.lewis.org/~jlewis/pgp for PGP public key_________
Current thread:
- APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA John Tran (Mar 16)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Andy Dills (Mar 16)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Richard A Steenbergen (Mar 16)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Jared Mauch (Mar 16)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 16)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Philip Smith (Mar 16)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Leo Bicknell (Mar 17)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA jlewis (Mar 17)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA bmanning (Mar 17)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Leo Bicknell (Mar 17)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA bdragon (Mar 20)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Stephen J. Wilcox (Mar 20)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA bdragon (Mar 21)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Richard A Steenbergen (Mar 16)
- Re: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Andy Dills (Mar 16)
- RE: APNIC returning 223/8 to IANA Mark Borchers (Mar 17)