nanog mailing list archives
Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies.
From: Ron da Silva <ron () aol net>
Date: Tue, 11 Mar 2003 10:41:36 -0500
On Sun, Mar 09, 2003 at 02:59:05PM -0500, jlewis () lewis org wrote:
I suspect AOL and Earthlink run their own DNSBLs primarily for the second reason. How would you convince them to trust and give up control to a central authority? Even if IANA were to create or bless some existing DNSBL and decree that all IP address holders will submit to testing or have their space revoked (yeah, that'll happen) there would still be those who weren't happy with the central DNSBL thus creating demand for additional ones.
Hmm...I would argue that every operator needs to run their own DNSBL. Some operators will simply mirror a central authority, others will ignore some or all of the data in the central authority and the simple case for some operators is to have an empty set. It would be very difficult to convince any operator to give up control of defining their own DNSBL (or even not having one at all). -ron
Current thread:
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies., (continued)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. Jack Bates (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. Jack Bates (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. jlewis (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. Jack Bates (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. E.B. Dreger (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. J.A. Terranson (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. jlewis (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. up (Mar 09)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. jlewis (Mar 11)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. Andy Walden (Mar 11)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. Ron da Silva (Mar 12)
- Re: Question concerning authoritative bodies. jlewis (Mar 12)