nanog mailing list archives
Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement- COPA Enforcement BAN
From: Richard Irving <rirving () onecall net>
Date: Fri, 07 Mar 2003 17:17:04 -0500
Another interesting point of "Roberts Rules of Procedure" for Internet Operational Protocols, so to speak... COPA has been struck down again. Your AUP's may have to be updated. ;) [Sorry NSP-SEC's for being redundant.. :*, shh...] Injunction against Enforcement of COPA, March 6, 2003. http://www.epic.org/free_speech/copa/ Excerpt: Court Strikes Down Censorship Law (Again). The Third Circuit Court of Appeals has, for the second time, ruled that the Child Online Protection Act (COPA) is unconstitutional. In a decision (pdf) issued on March 6, 2003, the court found that the law violates the First Amendment because it improperly restricts access to a substantial amount of online speech that is lawful for adults. The decision follows a Supreme Court decision that sent the case back to the appeals court, which had previously ruled that COPA was unconstitutional. EPIC is co-counsel in the case. ================================================= Supreme Court Maintains Ban on COPA Enforcement. ================================================= The Supreme Court on May 13, 2002, issued a decision on Congress's latest attempt to censor the Internet. The Court did not decide any of the core legal questions, but ordered a lower court to decide the case on a wider range of First Amendment issues. Meanwhile, a majority of justices appeared to have grave doubts about the law's ultimate constitutionality, and the Court left in place an injunction barring enforcement of the law. The case has to do with a law passed by Congress in 1998 called the Child Online Protection Act (COPA), a broad censorship law that severely restricts any speech on the Web that is "harmful to minors," and imposes steep fines and prison terms for violators. We don't make the laws people, we just abide by them. Sean Donelan wrote:
It difficult to tell from the article whether UK ISPs are refusing to cooperate with lawful requests from UK police, or if UK police are trying to get ISPs to give information without proper authorization. http://www.computerweekly.com/articles/article.asp?liArticleID=119873
Current thread:
- UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Sean Donelan (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Dan Hollis (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement- COPA Enforcement BAN Richard Irving (Mar 07)
- RE: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Mark Borchers (Mar 07)
- RE: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Dan Hollis (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Peter Galbavy (Mar 10)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Roland Perry (Mar 10)
- RE: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Dan Hollis (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Steven M. Bellovin (Mar 07)
- Re: UK ISPs not cooperating with law enforcement Neil J. McRae (Mar 08)