nanog mailing list archives
Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN?
From: Andrew Brown <twofsonet () graffiti com>
Date: Sun, 31 Dec 2000 20:25:18 -0500
Because private addresses have no global meaning, routing information about private networks shall not be propagated on inter-enterprise links, and packets with private source or destination addresses should not be forwarded across such links. so any isp which lets the outside world see a packet with a source in 1918 space is in direct violation of 1918.
...which is not the same as "any isp which allows the outside world to send it a packet with a source in 1918 space is in direct violation of 1918". my feeling is that if you're going to use 1918 space as backbone space (which i would never do, but many people do do), you should do your best to make sure that no one sees that those addresses are being used. not in the interest of security, mind you, but rather since there are other problems with letting people see your dirty laundry. i merely pointed out bt as a particularly egregious (in my eyes) offender of that tenet. my opinion, of course. -- |-----< "CODE WARRIOR" >-----| codewarrior () daemon org * "ah! i see you have the internet twofsonet () graffiti com (Andrew Brown) that goes *ping*!" andrew () crossbar com * "information is power -- share the wealth."
Current thread:
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN?, (continued)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Bill Fumerola (Dec 30)
- RE: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Randy Bush (Dec 31)
- RE: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Derek J. Balling (Dec 31)
- RE: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Randy Bush (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Stephen Stuart (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? John Fraizer (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Bill Woodcock (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Randy Bush (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Mark Mentovai (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Randy Bush (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Andrew Brown (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? John Hawkinson (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Dana Hudes (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Stephen Stuart (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Andrew Brown (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Stephen Stuart (Dec 31)
- RE: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Jason Lewis (Dec 31)
- Re: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Stephen Stuart (Dec 31)
- RE: RFC1918 addresses to permit in for VPN? Bill Woodcock (Dec 31)