Re: MTU of the Internet?

[Phil Howard <phil () charon milepost com>]

Jeff Stehman writes...

> On Wed, Feb 04, 1998 at 01:18:56PM -0500, Dennis Simpson wrote:
> > We recommend that clients who care about interactive response use small
> > MTUs, and clients who care about download speed use higher MTUs.
>
> There's an extremely annoying potential gotcha in having clients set
> lower MTUs.  At least one release of Netscape's web server set the
> Don't Fragment bit.  In the few cases we've seen, if there was not a 
> 1500 MTU pipe between server and client, the server could be reached,
> but no HTML would be downloaded.  Usually it's easier to work around
> the problem on the client end than convince the server admins they
> might want change things on their end.

If the client sets the MTU lower, that becomes the connection MTU and
MTU discovery doesn't take place.  The problem only occurs if there is
a router in between (not the client) that has a lower MTU than what the
connection is using, and hence the fragmentation (or discarding if DF
is on) occurs.

There's probably a whole thread due on whether DF should be set or not.
But there really are links that are smaller than 1500, such as SLIP at
1006.

IMHO setting DF should not be allowed where the MTU is greater than 576,
or whatever number today constitutes the "minimum reasonable requirement"
which I would say isn't larger than 1006.  Maybe in a few years we can
kiss SLIP bye-bye and make sure everything is 1500.

Netscape's web server is broken.  And in more ways than just the DF thing.

But then that begs the question, why 1500?  Why not 4000?  Or 32000?

-- 
Phil Howard | no7spam4 () no6where net eat07me7 () s5p5a7m7 edu stop9858 () no52ads4 edu
  phil      | suck1it4 () noplace9 net no6spam0 () no78ads3 org suck8it2 () spammer7 org
    at      | end2it19 () spam7mer net stop8810 () no4where net no4way24 () nowhere6 com
  milepost  | ads7suck () spam7mer edu crash826 () anyplace edu w5x0y6z2 () nowhere0 net
    dot     | suck6it0 () no8where com stop6it1 () dumbads4 org blow6me3 () dumbads6 com
  com       | end2ads4 () lame2ads com no0spam4 () no32ads4 com a3b1c5d8 () anywhere com