nanog mailing list archives
Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved]
From: "Dorian R. Kim" <dorian () blackrose org>
Date: Fri, 11 Jul 1997 23:14:56 -0400 (EDT)
On Fri, 11 Jul 1997, Robert Gutierrez wrote:
I hate to state the obvious, but don't you filter your own blocks from your other BGP peers? Inbound, I mean. Very simple:
Isn't this akin to wearing a condom nowadays in the 'net BGP routing warz.
Depends. Consider the following scenario: You have a customer X that is dual homed to provider A and provider B. X is numbered out of provider A's CIDR block. If the connection between X and provider A drops, and provider A filters A's own blocks, then while the connections remains lost, there is no connectivity between X and A. So simply filtering one's own blocks from peers can cause problems. The most rational thing to do is to block all except the specifics of dual homed customers, but whether one does that or not depends on level of configuration automation one has achieved, I think. -dorian
Current thread:
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Matthew Kaufman (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Andrew Partan (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Dorian R. Kim (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Chris Garner (Jul 11)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Matthew Kaufman (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Craig A. Huegen (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Phil Howard (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Craig A. Huegen (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Danny McPherson (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Robert Gutierrez (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Dorian R. Kim (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Charles Sprickman (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Barry A. Dykes (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Danny McPherson (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Chris Garner (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Danny McPherson (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Chris Garner (Jul 11)
- Re: weird BGP cisco-ism? [problem resolved] Chris Garner (Jul 11)