Interesting People mailing list archives
Re: Wi Air Force's Scare-Mongering Space Ad Shoves Facts Out of the Airlock
From: David Farber <dave () farber net>
Date: Tue, 13 May 2008 05:08:30 -0700
________________________________________ From: David P. Reed [dpreed () reed com] Sent: Tuesday, May 13, 2008 8:01 AM To: DV Henkel-Wallace Cc: David Farber Subject: Re: [IP] Wi Air Force's Scare-Mongering Space Ad Shoves Facts Out of the Airlock Right. It's not your framing - it's the fashionable framing, as I said. I personally think it's important to question the assumption that if some military power makes the world safe, more makes us safer (and other such taboo questions). We'll never know, of course, but Churchill bombed and gassed native tribespeoplein a number of places, such as Iraq and India, *before* Hitler did similar tests in Guernica, so that might suggest that Churchill and Hitler were the joint cause of WWII. It's clear from the historical record that Churchill, even more than Hitler, loved military action and pursued it whether necessary or not. It's also clear that he hated "the Hun" - and may have enjoyed provoking exactly the situation that made him able to tell the story of his own "heroism". Did Churchill help stop WWII? It's hard to escape the thought that perhaps he "broke it, so he bought it". He's a greater man than Bush/Cheney. They can't even end what they started. DV Henkel-Wallace wrote:
Well the question of course framed in military terms from the beginning. But if you accept the idea you must have a military you start down that slippery slope. I think it would have been worth forcing the Navy to find a de-icing solution that didn't turn Moffett Field into a superfund site. I think the case is much harder to make for active combat. And your question of keeping space nonmilitarised: my point is that armies generally ignore treaties at will as war could be (inadequately in my mind) considered a result of treaty failure. It's really no different from having to worry about locking down your network-connected computer: those script kiddies aren't _supposed_ to try to break in, but they do. Ironically I watched The Day the Earth Stood Still with my son for the (his) first time last week...perhaps that's what moved me to write back. -g PS: the observation of the Geneva Conventions by all sides in the European theatre of WWII is extraordinary and remarkable and it's astonishing that it isn't more widely discussed.From: "David P. Reed" <dpreed () reed com> Date: May 12, 2008 3:26:30 PM EDT To: David Farber <dave () farber net> I find the framing of this discussion in terms of "what military operations require" quite interesting. To eliminate the blinders, consider if we framed inter-governmental economic interactions in terms of "what counterfeiters require" or "what international fraudsters (such as the "Nigerian" cons) require". While it is fashionable to think of "the military" as heroic and "intelligence professionals" as ethical, at least to their own countrymen, to others they are murderers and thieves. Perhaps we can keep space free of activities and people who are (in their own nations) heroic and ethically good only in an extremely narrow contextual perspective. Should we wear the blinders of ultra-nationalists when there are no nations in space?
------------------------------------------- Archives: http://www.listbox.com/member/archive/247/=now RSS Feed: http://www.listbox.com/member/archive/rss/247/ Powered by Listbox: http://www.listbox.com
Current thread:
- Fwd: Wi Air Force's Scare-Mongering Space Ad Shoves Facts Out of the Airlock David Farber (May 11)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: Wi Air Force's Scare-Mongering Space Ad Shoves Facts Out of the Airlock David Farber (May 11)
- Re: Wi Air Force's Scare-Mongering Space Ad Shoves Facts Out of the Airlock David Farber (May 12)
- Wi Air Force's Scare-Mongering Space Ad Shoves Facts Out of the Airlock David Farber (May 12)
- Wi Air Force's Scare-Mongering Space Ad Shoves Facts Out of the Airlock David Farber (May 12)
- Re: Wi Air Force's Scare-Mongering Space Ad Shoves Facts Out of the Airlock David Farber (May 13)