Re: Why TCP is more secure than UDP?

[Alex Cernat <alexutzu () cernat ro>]

paavan.shah () gmail com wrote:
> It is said that UDP is considered more vulnerable to spoofing than TCP?
>
> Can anyone point me to any document/link which describes TCP is more secure than UDP
>   
The main difference between TCP and UDP is that UDP is a 
'connectionless' protocol. As you probably know, when you want to 
communicate on TCP, you open an connection, a stream of data. The TCP 
layer knows how to deliver the data in the right order (even if at IP 
layer the packets get scrambled and came by multiple routes and in 
multiple order). Of course, if a packet is lost and no retransmition is 
successful, the connection is considered broken and the stream is 
closed. TCP has some way of protections, like tcp window, random 
generation of tcp connection codes (in syn and syn/ack packets) and so 
on (this is general culture, i'm not an guru in tcp/ip).
UDP is a connectionless protocol. That meens that is no 'stream' of data 
defined, and you send packet by packet (in fact group of bytes by group 
of bytes), and there is no guarantee that the destination will ever 
receive that data (and in case of error, there is no error message at 
the protocol level). Sure, anyone can ask: what the hell was this 
protocol being invented. Well, there aren't many programs/protocols 
which use UDP (better said - 'normal' programs), but UDP is beeing used 
in application protocols like NFS, VoIP, and many others. Why ? Because 
sometimes it doesn't matter if some packets are lost in the way (like 
VoIP, it is no use in retrasmition, because it will be too late). Or 
like in NFS (better said in old NFS, in v4 I believe it is working with 
TCP), they've implemented an ack algorithm at application level. So, 
they say it's faster that a similar implementation on TCP. No comment.
So, as a conclusion, a TCP may be a little secure that UDP. But most 
important thing, if you want a secure connection, is not to relay on 
those simple protocols, and use some SSL/TLS or other encryption system. 
If someone can brake a tcp/udp connection, and flooding with some 
garbage packets (remember Mitnick?), it's almost impossible (unless you 
are from NSA or something, in case we can say "it's very hard") to break 
an encryption layer without anyone can see.

Alex